Living with a
Small Office Home Office Network
This paper documents our experience setting up and using a SOHO (small office home office) network over many years. It offers guidance selecting a broadband ISP, internet connection sharing, presents wired and wireless LAN options and discusses numerous network services.
We have DSL provided by a CLEC (competitive local exchange carrier). An ADSL2+ router is connected to a 16-port Gig Ethernet switch allowing multiple devices to share the connection and talk to each other. An 802.11n Access Point provides Wi-Fi connectivity throughout house and yard. LAN services include: file sharing, automatic PC backup, printing, NTP timeserver, private internal website, multiple DIY home automation controllers and cell phone Wi-Fi offload.
We use a hosting service for our business web server and e-mail. Hosting moves web site traffic off the broadband connection. It significantly eases the task of securing the local network. Having a registered domain provides a persistent email address reducing risk of losing contact with colleagues and friends.
We switched to a MVNO (mobile virtual network operator) for cell phone service a few years ago. The company has an interesting technology wrinkle; the phones default to Wi-Fi whenever possible to minimize cellular usage.
Table of Contents
In mid-1998 I set up a home network as part of starting a consulting business and wanted to learn about design and operation of a SOHO (small office home office) network. Back then residential networks were fairly rare and some ISPs even prohibited them. Today home networks are ubiquitous and the proliferation of portable devices means residential customers often use a combination of wired and wireless connectivity. It has been fun documenting how our network has evolved over the decades.
We began with a V.90 dialup connection, Wingate connection sharing software running on a Win98 laptop and a small 10 Mbps Ethernet hub. Our current internet connection is 8Mbps/1Mbps ADSL2+ provided by a CLEC First Light Fiber. A TP-Link TD-8817 single port ADSL2+ router provides internet sharing. Speed is relatively low by current standards but adequate for our needs. Over the years the LAN has expanded beyond my home office to encompass the entire house with a total of 24 Ethernet drops serviced by a Netgear Prosafe Plus GS116Ev2 16-port Gig Ethernet switch. A Netgear WN802Tv2 802.11N Access Point provides Wi-Fi connectivity. To augment our backup generator I built a simple DC UPS to maintain critical LAN equipment during a power outage.
With the end of Win 7 support imminent I purchased a couple off lease HP Z230 SFF desktops for myself and my wife. Normally during an O/S upgrade I recycle a PC to function as a poor man’s server. This time I purchased an off lease Lenovo ThinkPad T420 laptop. That reduced server power consumption from 80 watts to 20. Unlike a desktop the laptop has its own screen. I found a nifty software application called Input Director to share the main workstation keyboard and mouse instead of using a KVM. I did recycle one of the SFF desktop as a test PC continuing to run Win 7 and dual boot Ubuntu.
I use a Belkin 4-port KVM (keyboard, video and mouse) to switch between: 1) main PC, 2) dual boot PC and 3) unused spare. The 4th KVM port is used for testing. I cabled it along with Ethernet and power making it easy to temporally connect a computer for setup and testing.
Netflix no longer supports our WD TV Live Hub; we are now using a Roku Express connected to our main TV for streaming. Even though we have relatively slow internet connection streaming has not been a problem but probably would be if we had many simultaneous streams
Over the last few years I’ve built several home automation systems for various functions: greenhouse, wood heat, window ventilator, aquarium and most recently an outdoor temperature logger. Each of these controllers has a web interface requiring an Ethernet connection. I’ve posted details about these and other home automation projects on the writings page of my website.
Acronis True Image provides automatic online backup of PC data to the server. For offline backup we use several different flavors of external USB drives.
This paper discusses internet access and LAN (local area network) components. A separate paper on my web site goes into detail about the various methods and tradeoffs of internet access. Structured wiring for telephone and Ethernet is covered in detail. The security and troubleshooting topics provides information to maintain the network and protect it from intruders.
Lastly I discuss registering a domain name and running a public internet web server. It does not take much effort to set up a simple web site and cost is low. Even if you do not run a business registering a domain provides a consistent email address and having a web site gives you tremendous flexibility over your internet presence. For a few dollars per month it is a lot of bang for the buck.
This report is not intended as a competitive product review. The market is constantly changing; any attempt to do so quickly becomes outdated. Rather, it discusses how we implemented specific requirements. For up to date product reviews the reader is directed to the many publications and articles on the subject.
Figure 1 Schmidt Consulting Network
This section discusses some of the important technology involved in setting up a SOHO network. While not essential reading it is helpful to know what is going on under the hood.
The internet was created 50 years ago as a means for government and academics to share expensive mainframe computers. Today it is the preferred method to access all sorts of digital information: data, voice and video. Internet is a contraction of Inter Networking, literally a network of networks. Creation of the Word Wide Web (WWW) in the 1990’s vastly expanded internet popularity by providing a Graphical User Interface (GUI) on what until then had been text based. Some equate World Wide Web with the internet. The two are not synonymous. The web is simply one, admittedly a very popular, application supported by the internet.
The internet is a packet network that transports data from one host to another over a network shared by many users. The internet is fundamentally different than the legacy PSTN (public switched telephone network). The telephone network establishes a dedicated path for the duration of the call. This reservation exists whether it is needed or not. The internet on the other hand works on chunks of data called packets. Packets are presented to the internet on an as required basis. At each hop a router examines the packet’s destination address field to determine how best to forward it toward the destination.
ISP (internet service provider) connects end users to the internet. The incredible popularity of the internet is driving demand for higher speed at lower cost. Connection between ISP and customer is often called the last-mile. I prefer the term first-mile, because it elevates end user’s importance. The internet’s value proposition is its ability to connect end points. Without end points the network is useless.
Even though we are in a fairly rural area wired broadband is available from multiple sources:
We have FirstLight ADSL bundled with POTS phone service. They rent the customer copper loop from the ILEC but provide their own electronics. Typical sync speed is 7996 Mbps down/999kbps up. This is a significant improvement from the 3360/864 kbps speed provided by FairPoint and previously Verizon ADSL of 1792/448. Unlike Consolidated the CLEC does not cap the speed. Sync speed varies as a result of circuit characteristics. If phone loop is very short maximum speed is 24/1 Mbps. In our case the circuit is pretty long so speed is lower but still a very significant improvement over what we had before. Another benefit is the CLEC uses DHCP rather than PPPoE. This provides a minor performance improvement but more importantly is more stable than PPPoE. Prior to switching to the CLEC the majority of our DSL outages were due to not being able to maintain the PPPoE session.
Non-technical folks often confuse latency with speed. Latency is how long it takes a packet to get from point A to B. Speed is rate bits are transmitted across the network. If you are downloading a large file speed is important, latency less so. If on the other hand you are conducting a Voice over IP (VoIP) phone call latency is critical to maintaining good two way communication.
A useful analogy is to think of a truck full of DVDs going from Point A to B. From the time truck begins its journey latency is high – while the truck travels to destination recipient can do nothing. However once it arrives communication speed is very high due to the tremendous capacity of the DVDs. Conversely a dialup connection has low latency since it only takes a few milliseconds for data to arrive at its destination but speed is very low – limited by telephone network performance. For a more in-depth explanation see “It’s the Latency Stupid.”
The URL (uniform resource locator) is a human friendly handle rather than the numeric IP addresses. Translation of URL to IP address is performed by DNS (domain name system). Domain names are hierarchal, evaluated right to left. The highest-level of the tree called Root is implied. Next is the TLD (top-level domain) these are the COM, EDU, ORG, GOV, UK, TV domains of the world. As the internet expanded each country was assigned a unique two-letter top-level domain. For example the TLD for the United Kingdom is UK. Various agencies are responsible for name registration, called registrars. The role of the registrar is to insure each registered name is unique within a top-level domain. For example when we were registering our domain name the name schmidt.com was already assigned so we choose tschmidt.com.
Often an organization needs to create sub domains such as www.tschmidt.com for web access, mail.tschmidt.com for email or product.tschmidt.com for product info. Once the domain name is registered it is guaranteed to be unique so the owner is free to add as many sub domains as desired.
When a domain is registered the registrar database contains a list of Nameservers that provide authoritive information about the site. Authoritive Nameservers are managed by the site administrator and contain all the information necessary to access the various servers within that domain.
When a URL is entered into the browser, such as http://www.google.com/, browser first checks to see if the host is on the LAN. Windows name resolution looks in the Hosts file to see if an address has been entered manually then it uses NetBIOS over IP to search local machines. This is a broadcast mechanism and works well on small LANs but does not scale well. If host name is not found locally translation request is passed to the DNS Resolver.
Let’s trace what happens when we look up http://www.google.com. Since the Google URL is not located on the LAN it is passed to the DNS system. The highest level is root. The naming hierarchy includes an implied dot (.) to the right of the TLD this is called the root. The DNS Resolver is preprogrammed with the IP address of several root Nameservers. The request goes to one of the root Nameservers that returns the address of the Nameserver for the .COM top-level domain (TLD) since Google is in the COM TLD. Then the COM Nameserver is queried for the address of the Google Nameserver. The server returns the address of the authoritive Nameserver for the Google domain. It is important to note root Nameserver does not know the address of the Google servers other than the Google Nameserver. Google Nameserver is then asked for the address of the desired host. Often sites create sub domains for specific servers, the process continues until the address of the desired host is determined. Once browser learns host’s IP address it is able to communicate. This is a very superficial view of how DNS works. For a more in-depth view see DNS Complexity by Paul Vixie.
Obviously going thought this multistep process each time one needs to translate a URL is rather time consuming. To speed up the process DNS resolvers’ cache recently used information. DNS records have a time to live (TTL) parameter indicating how long cached information may be used before it must be refreshed. URL name lookup is normally accomplished in a few milliseconds.
As the internet becomes ever more pervasive attention has been drawn to lack of DNS security. Hackers are able to easily poison cached DNS information. Doing so allows an attacker to redirect browsers to compromised site for nefarious purposes. A high priority initiative is to implement Domain Name System Security Extensions (DNSSEC) to counteract this sort of attack and increase level of confidence in DNS.
The internet is a routed network. This is very different then broadcast discovery scheme used locally by Ethernet or circuit switching used by telephone network. When a computer wants to communicate with a resource not available locally it forwards the packet to gateway router. The gateway router is the interface between the local network (LAN) and the internet. The router forwards packets to the proper destination or to next router in the chain. In order to learn network topology routers use a variety of techniques to communicate among themselves such as RIP and OSPF. ISP routers forward incoming packets to customers and customer originated packets to the internet backbone. Each router in the chain forwards packets closer to the destination until the packet ultimately arrives at its destination. It is not uncommon to have ten to twenty hops between sender and destination.
The routing task for typical residential router is trivial as there is usually only one connection to the internet. The router simply forwards all packets to the ISP’s edge router.
Doing a trace route to an internet host provides a graphic indication of how routing works. Here is a trace route from my east coast home office to the DSLreports web site
Tracing route to dslreports.com [184.108.40.206] over a maximum of 30 hops:
1 <1 ms <1 ms <1 ms 192.168.2.1
2 34 ms 34 ms 34 ms xx.milford1-1.nh.g4.net [220.127.116.11]
3 36 ms 34 ms 36 ms 18.104.22.168
4 34 ms 35 ms 34 ms manchester0-8.nh.G4.net [22.214.171.124]
5 36 ms 36 ms 36 ms 216-107-229-217.static.firstlight.net [126.96.36.199]
6 38 ms 37 ms 37 ms 66-109-52-101.tvc-ip.com [188.8.131.52]
7 40 ms 40 ms 40 ms be13.albnypscr1.ip.firstlight.net [184.108.40.206]
8 * 39 ms 40 ms be23.albynypsbr1.ip.firstlight.net [220.127.116.11]
9 65 ms 64 ms 65 ms equinix-chi.liquidweb.com [18.104.22.168]
10 73 ms 71 ms 72 ms lw-dc3-core1.rtr.liquidweb.com [22.214.171.124]
11 70 ms 71 ms 70 ms lw-dc3-storm1.rtr.liquidweb.com [126.96.36.199]
12 71 ms 71 ms 70 ms www.dslreports.com [188.8.131.52]
Most internet traffic is between one sender and one receiver (unicast). Multicast emulates traditional broadcast one-to-many model. This is a more efficient way to stream identical information to many endpoints. Unfortunately even though specification is mature not many ISPs have implemented multicast. In general if you listen to internet radio or TV it is being transmitted as unicast.
There are two basic ways information is conveyed over the internet; TCP (transmission control protocol) and UDP (user datagram protocol). TCP creates a session where the receiver acknowledges each packet and lost or damaged packets are resent. This is ideal for file transfer type communication. Recovery from missing or corrupt packets is more important than latency. With UDP transmitter sends data without expecting feedback from receiver. UDP is commonly used with streaming audio and video transmission where latency is more important than accuracy and insufficient time exists to recover from transmission errors. If an error occurs it is up to the receiver to deal with the missing data as best it can.
The internet is an egalitarian best effort network. This works amazing well for transferring large chunks of data from point A to point B. The network continues to operate in the presence of all sorts of impairments and failures. However: best effort does not work as well with latency sensitive applications such as telephony and streaming media. For example during a Voice over IP (VoIP) phone call latency should be under 150ms. Excessive delay makes carrying on a conversation difficult and with extreme delay virtually impossible. Streaming media is less sensitive to latency as long as the average data rate exceeds playback rate. When a stream is started an elastic buffer is filled prior to beginning playback. The buffer fills and empties dynamically. As long as latency does not allow the buffer to completely empty the effect is hidden from the user.
QoS problems typically do not occur on the LAN where bandwidth is plentiful. The most common chokepoint is first-mile access; the ISP’s upload speed since most residential internet connections are highly asymmetric and often much slower than a LAN. Download speed is many times that of upload. When a switch or router encounters congestion it buffers incoming packets until it is able to forward them. QoS (Quality of Service) metrics allows latency critical packets go to the head of the queue. This simple strategy works well if latency critical traffic is a small percent of total so bumping its priority has little effect on other traffic. QoS marks packets with a (Diffserv) priority level. When congestion occurs higher value packets are delivered as quickly as possible. Lower value packets are delayed or discarded. QoS services allow more graceful degradation by moving high priority packets to the head of the queue. QoS is not a panacea, it does not create more capacity, and it simply redefines winners and losers.
When a host begins transmission it has no idea how fast the intervening links are between it and the remote host. Switched Ethernet uses back pressure to prevent overwhelming slower links. An Ethernet receiver asks the transmitter to stop sending data by sending it a pause frame. This occurs if the outgoing switch port becomes congested.
At the IP level transmitter uses a technique called slow-start by sending a few packets then waiting for acknowledge. The faster ACKs are received the more packets the transmitter sends per unit of time. TCP RWIN (receive window) parameter determines how many unacknowledged packets can be outstanding before the transmitter must stop transmitting and waits for an acknowledgement.
Each IP device (host) must have an address. Addresses may be assigned: manually, automatically by a DHCP (dynamic host configuration protocol) server or by the client itself using APIPA (automatic private IP addressing). Historically a system administrator manually configured each host with a static address and other IP parameters. This was laborious and error prone. DHCP simplifies the task by automating address allocation. When a host detects it has a network connection it transmits a DHCP discovery message. If the LAN contains a DHCP server the server responds with all the information the client needs to utilize the network. DHCP has been extended to allow automatic configuration if the client cannot find a DHCP server. In that case client assigns itself an address from the AutoIP address pool. AutoIP is convenient for small LANs that use IP and do not have access to a DHCP server. This occurs most commonly when two PC’s are directly connected. IPV6 adds several additional ways to automatically configure hosts.
IPv4 assigns each host a 32-bit address, resulting in a maximum internet population of about 4 billion hosts. Due to IPv4 address scarcity it is common practice for ISPs to charge for additional addresses. Address exhaustion has been a concern for a long time. CIDR (classless inter-domain routing) and NAT (network address translation) are two techniques used to delay the day of reckoning. Next generation IP, version 6, expands address space to 128 bits. This is a truly gigantic number. While IPv6 holds much promise it entails wholesale overhaul of the internet. Such change is always resisted until one has no choice but to go through the pain of conversion. My ISP does not currently support IPv6 so I have limited experience with it.
IPv4 addresses are expressed in dotted decimal notation, four decimal numbers separated by periods, nnn.nnn.nnn.nnn. The 32-bit address is divided into four 8-bit fields called octets. Each field has a range of 0-255. The smallest address is 0.0.0.0 and largest 255.255.255.255.
IP addresses consist of two parts a Network-Prefix and Host address. Subnetting allows IP addresses to be assigned efficiently and simplifies routing. The subnet mask defines the boundary between network and host portions of the address. Hosts within a subnet communicate directly with one another. Hosts on different subnets use routers to forward packets from one subnet to another.
In our network all computers are on a single subnet: 255.255.255.0 allowing up to 254 hosts (computers) also called a /24 (pronounced slash 24) subnet because the first 24-bits of address are fixed. Host addresses are allocated from the last octet (8-bits). The reason for 254 rather than 256 hosts is lowest address is reserved as the network address and highest address is used for multicast.
When internet was initially developed the divide between network prefix and host address was embedded within the address itself, rather than set by a subnet mask. These were called address classes, lettered A – E.
Class A – first octet is in the range 1 – 126 (0XXXXXXXb). 8-bits reserved for network portion leaving 24 for host addresses. 24-bits provide 16,777,213 host addresses. The lowest address is reserved as the network address, highest for broadcast. The 127 octet is reserved for test purposes.
Class B – first octet is in the range 128 – 191 (10XXXXXXb). 16-bits reserved for network portion leaving 16 for host addresses. 16-bits provide 65,533 host addresses.
Class C – first octet is in the range 192 – 223 (110XXXXXb). 24-bits reserved for network portion leaving 8 for host addresses. 8-bits provide 254 host addresses.
Class D – first octet is in the range 224 – 239 (1110XXXXb). Class D networks reserved for multicasting.
Class E - first octet is in the range 240 – 255 (1111XXXXb). Class E networks reserved for experimental use.
It became clear very early that allocating addresses this way was very inefficient. Class C was too small for many organizations and Class A wastefully large. CIDR was developed to allow network prefix be fixed at any bit boundary. CIDR using variable subnet mask is now universal and Class based routing of historic interest, although one still hears reference to Class A, B, and C networks.
127.0.0.1 is the Loopback local host address. This is useful for testing to makes sure the network stack. Sending data to the Loopback address causes it to be received without actually going out over the physical network. The entire /8 block is reserved for local loopback but by convention 127.0.0.1 is used as the loopback address...
IP sessions are typically one to one, host A communicates with host B. It is also possible for a host to broadcast to multiple hosts. IANA reserved several address blocks for multicast.
Multicast address block
224.000.000.000 – 184.108.40.206 (224/8 – 239/8 prefix)
During work on IPv4 address shortage RFC 1918 reserved three blocks of private addresses. Private addresses are ideal for our purposes because they are not used on public internet. This allows them to be used and reused without risk of colliding with internet hosts. This eliminates the need to obtain a block of routable addresses from the ISP. Internal hosts are assigned an address from RFC 1918 private address pool.
Excerpt from IETF RFC 1918 Address Allocation for Private internets:
Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) reserved the following three blocks of the IP address space for private internets:
10.0.0.0 - 10.255.255.255 (10/8 prefix)
172.16.0.0 - 172.31.255.255 (172.16/12 prefix)
192.168.0.0 - 192.168.255.255 (192.168/16 prefix)
We will refer to the first block as "24-bit block", the second as
"20-bit block", and to the third as "16-bit" block. Note that (in pre-CIDR notation) the first block is nothing but a single class A network number, while the second block is a set of 16 contiguous class B network numbers, and third block is a set of 256 contiguous class C network numbers.
An enterprise that decides to use IP addresses out of the address space defined in this document can do so without any coordination with IANA or an internet registry. The address space can thus be used by many enterprises. Addresses within this private address space will only be unique within the enterprise, or the set of enterprises which choose to cooperate over this space so they may communicate with each other in their own private internet.
A fourth block of private IP addresses is reserved for APIPA, (automatic private IP addressing). If a host is configured to obtain a dynamic address and a DHCP server cannot be found the host assigns itself an address from this pool of reserved addresses. Host picks an address from the APIPA address pool, and tests to see if it is already in use by trying to contact that IP address. If the address is not in use it assigns itself the address. If the address is in use it picks another at random and tries again.
AutoIP address block:
169.254.0.0 - 169.254.255.255 (169.254/16 prefix)
APIPA is useful for tiny networks that do not include a DHCP server. Before APIPA a user had to manually configure address and subnet mask to set up a simple IP network.
Residential ISP customers are typically assigned a single IP address. This limits customer to connecting a single computer to the internet. NAT (network address translation) is used to convert multiple private LAN IP addresses to/from the single public IP address assigned by the ISP. To enable multiple sessions of the same type to operate simultaneously Port numbers also need to be changed. NAT allows a virtually unlimited number of devices, assigned private IP addresses, to share an ISP account even if the ISP only provides a single IP address. NAT is one of the services built into residential routers.
An internet host is able to carry on multiple simultaneous communications sessions. This raises the question how does the computer know how to respond to specific incoming packets? While writing this paper my mail program is checking e-mail every few minutes, I’m listening to a web based radio program and from time to time getting information from a multitude of web sites. Each TCP or UDP packet includes a port number. Port numbers are 16-bit unsigned values that range from 0-65,535. The low port numbers 0-1023 are called well-known ports; they are assigned by IANA the internet Assigned Number Authority when a service is defined. Software uses the well-known port to make initial contact. Once connection is established high numbered ports are used during the transfer. For example: when you enter a URL to access a web site the browser automatically uses port 80. This is the well know port for web servers. Once the connection is established client and server agree on high numbered ports to use to actually transfer data.
IPv4 is the predominant protocol used on the internet today. A defining characteristic is its 32-bit address space. The IPv4 address field is 32-bits wide able to address a maximum of 4,292,967,295 hosts. 4 billion is a pretty large number and it certainly was back in the 1980’s when the internet was limited to a few educational intuitions and the federal government.
To put 4 billion into perspective present worldwide population is almost 8 billion people. It is true that not everyone has internet access but many do and those who have access often have multiple devices. At any given moment in our home there are dozens of devices connected to the internet.
The address limitation of IPv4 was recognized long ago. While mechanisms such as private addresses and NAT have extended the life of IPv4 it is clear the address range needs to be expanded. A watershed event occurred February 2011 when the last IPv4 address blocks were handed out to regional registrars.
The successor to IPv4 is IPv6 with a massively expanded address range of 128-bits. IPv6 brings a host of improvements to the internet but because it is not directly backward compatible with IPv4 adoption has been very slow. Companies and service providers are faced with a typical chicken and egg problem. There is no first mover advantage. Being the only one able to support IPv6 has no advantage.
A modem is usually required to convert the subscriber’s network, typically Ethernet, to the signaling and physical interface used to connect to the ISP. In the case of DSL it is an ADSL (asymmetric digital subscriber line) or VDSL (very high speed DSL) modem, Cable internet uses some flavor of DOCSIS (data over cable service interface specification). Wireless internet access, either Cellular or fixed, use a modem in conjunction with a radio transmitter/receiver. Lastly the holy grail of first-mile broadband, fiber optic is typically a version of PON (passive optical network) terminated at an ONT (optical network termination) at the subscriber. The granddaddy of data communications the dialup modem uses the voice grade telephone network limiting speed to no greater then 56kbps compared to multimegabit speed of the other technologies. That can be useful for some specialized remote access applications and even slower dialup modems are used for alarm dialers where connect time is more important than transfer speed. But for general purpose internet usage dialup it is almost unusable since most web sites are optimized for multimegabit per second access.
When we first set up our SOHO network in 1998 used Wingate connections sharing software running on a laptop to share a v.90 dialup connection. Over time we have used several different modems and routers as our ISP and connection speed changed. Currently we use a CLEC (competitive local exchange carrier) to provide our ADSL2+ internet connection and landline telephone. My preference is a combo DSL modem/router because it makes access to low level modem info easy. Having access to modem status is handy for troubleshooting. Our current modem/router is a TP-Link TD-8817 single port router.
Since we have DSL the rest of this section will be about DSL modems. For other ways to access the internet check out: First-mile internet access on the writings page of my site
ADSL takes advantage of the fact the subscriber telephone copper circuit has unused capacity. Analog voice uses only a tiny fraction of available wire capacity. With clever engineering that unused capacity can be used to send and receive data. A tremendous amount of engineering has gone into DSL to allow 100 year old telephone copper loop deliver multimegabit internet service. ADSL modems use a technique called DMT (discrete multi-tone) to divide available capacity into small chunks and send a few bits per second over each separate tone. DMT has the advantage of being able to work around impairments by changing the number of bits sent in each tone.
DSL is a distance limited technology. The signal weakens as it travels down the wire and picks up noise limiting connection speed. The higher the frequency the faster it degrades with length. One does not know in advance how fast the connection will be until it is turned up. ISPs often market DSL as “up to xx Mbps” causing customer frustration when actual speed is less than marketing representation. Customer must be within 18,000 feet (3.5 miles) of the central office or remote terminal to qualify at all. The closer you are the more likely to obtain high speed.
ITU ADSL specification has gone through several enhancements. ADSL2 and ADSL2+ delivers higher speed and longer range then first generation equipment. ADSL delivered up to 8 Mbps down (toward customer and 1 Mbps up. ADSL2 increased download speed to 12 Mbps, upload is unchanged. ADSL2+ doubles maximum download speed to 24 Mbps over relatively short distances. Another standard, VDSL2 is able to deliver even higher speed but only over a few thousand feet of cable.
Figure 2 DSL End to End
Because DSL shares the same circuit as POTS (plain old telephone system) filters are required at both ends to prevent high frequency DSL signals from interfering with telephone operation and the voice grade equipment from degrading DSL. Customers have the option to use an in-line filter at each non-DSL device or install a whole house POTS/DSL splitter. To reduce deployment cost rather than sending a tech out to install a whole house splitter ISPs typically provide a self-install kit including inline filters for the customer to self-install. I’ll talk more about wiring in a later section. The preferred implementation is to use a whole house POTS/DSL splitter as it does a better job isolating DSL from POTS and eliminates the need to have a filter at each non-DSL device.
Because DSL uses copper phone lines it is sensitive to electrical impulse noise. To make the signal more resistant ADSL adds redundant bits to each frame called forward error correction (FEC). If noise corrupts some of the bits the receiver is able to correct the corrupt data as long as it is not too extensive. If too many bits are corrupt the frame cannot be recovered and needs to be resent. To increase noise tolerance DSL interleaves multiple frames. When the receiver deinterleaves the data noise damaged is now spread over multiple frames increasing the odds receiver will be able to recover the data without needing to have it retransmitted.
As with any engineering tradeoff there is no free lunch. Interleave increases latency because multiple frames must be queued up prior to transmission. The improved effective signal to noise ratio (SNR) is advantageous for file transfer and streaming media. Correcting corrupt data on the fly eliminates the need for retransmission. With streaming media there is not enough time to request retransmission so application needs to fake the missing data, resulting in audible or visual anomalies. How annoying depends on how much data has gone missing.
On the other hand latency sensitive applications benefit from fastpath, because it reduces latency at the expense of signal integrity. Fastpath reduces DSL latency by about 10ms. In most cases this savings is swamped out by other end-to-end internet latencies. But if you are a gamer and your line stats are good may be worthwhile experimenting with fastpath.
Several years ago we switched to a CLEC (competitive local exchange carrier). They rent copper subscriber circuits from Consolidated Communication (was FairPoint/Verizon), our ILEC (incumbent local exchange carrier), and co-locate their equipment in Consolidated central offices. First Light markets ADSL differently than a typical ILEC as it does not impose a speed cap. Speed is based solely on what the circuit is able to handle. We were pleasantly surprised to see sync speed increase to about 8 Mbps down and 1 Mbps up. Download is now over twice the speed we had with FairPoint and almost five times with Verizon DSL, all over the same copper pair.
Figure 3 Router Status Page during DSL Initialization
The Wide Area Network (WAN) side of the modem is responsible for encoding and recovering bits over the phone line and extending the ISP’s network to the customer. Often times the ADSL modem is combined with a residential NAT router, Ethernet switch and in some cases a Wi-Fi Access Point to deliver multiple services in one inexpensive combo device. However the modem function remains the same, to interface to the phone line and connect to the ISP equipment.
The main functions of the ADSL modem are:
Most DSL connections use ATM (asynchronous transfer mode) to transport data over the DSL link. ATM is designed to transport low latency digital telephone traffic. Data is transported in 53-byte cells of which 48 carry data the other 5 are overhead. ATM is a legacy of circuit switched telephone network and uses virtual circuits. When setting up the modem need to specify the Virtual Path Identifier (VPI) and Virtual Channel Identifier (VCI). Unfortunately when used for data ATM adds significant overhead, the so called ATM cell tax.
There are various methods of transporting IP packets over ATM, called adaption layers. You need to use the method specified by your ISP.
Once the modem is able to successfully transport data over the DSL link the next step in the process is to configure internet Protocol (IP) parameters so the computer or router is able to access the internet. Each device requires an IP address and a subnet mask that identifies the network and host portion of the address. To communicate with other devices on the internet it needs to know the default gateway server address. This is the address the computer uses to hand off packets when the destination host is not on the LAN. Lastly devices need the address of the DNS server to translate URL name to the IP address of the distant server.
The modem is transparent to IP. What is being configured is the WAN (wide area network) interface which is either the outward facing router interface or if only a single PC is being used the computer itself.
There are three methods ISPs use to configure customer equipment:
Most business accounts are configured statically to facilitate running servers. With a static assignment the IP address never changes. The ISP sends customer configuration information and the customer in turn manually configures equipment. Changes require manual intervention by the ISP and customer.
Residential accounts typically use DHCP or PPPoE. DHCP works much the same as having a PC connected to a LAN. When modem powers up its first synchronizes to the DSL line then searches for a DHCP server. The DHCP server communicates IP settings to the router. Consolidated and most other ILEC's use PPPoE (point-to-point protocol over Ethernet) it works much the same as with dialup only much faster. PPPoE requires customer enter a user name and password. The downside of PPPoE is slightly higher overhead and the need to log in and maintain a persistent user session.
First Light uses DHCP rather than PPPoE for residential accounts. In the past we would often lose internet access due to inability to maintain a PPPoE session even though DSL itself was working correctly. DHCP has proven to be much more reliable and has slightly less overhead than PPPoE.
The downside of PPPoE is that customer needs to login and ISP maintain an active session. Being an encapsulation protocol PPPoE reserves 8 bytes of each 1500 byte packet reducing maxim transmission unit (MTU) to 1492.
Internet packets are limited to 1500 bytes. PPPoE adds 8 bytes of overhead to each packet reducing maximum payload size to 1492. Too large internet packets can be fragmented and reassembled. However many residential routers do not implement fragmentation. Even when properly implemented fragmentation incurs a significant performance penalty since an over large packet is split into two smaller ones with attendant IP overhead.
A better solution is to limit packet size so fragmentation/reassembly is not required. Windows TCP/IP protocol stack implements path MTU discovery to automatically limit packet size so fragmentation is not needed. When PPPoE is used maximum transmission unit (MTU) is 1452 bytes: 1452 bytes data + 40 bytes TCP/IP overhead + 8 bytes PPPoE = 1500 bytes. A good indication of packet fragmentation is if sending a little data <1452 bytes works but larger files do not.
The main downside of PPPoE is not the slight extra overhead of the 8 bytes (.6%) but the difficulty maintaining the session. If the session terminates connection is lost until the user logs in again. With a modem this happens automatically so normally hidden from the user. With both Verizon and FairPoint we would normally go days with the same PPPoE session so did not notice the momentary interruption. However on numerous occasions with both ISPs had multiple episodes where modem would log back in and almost immediately be dropped or account was not recognized at all for hours on end. I’m happy to be rid of PPPoE.
Residential accounts are typically bridged. This means each customer is connected to the ISP’s LAN, much like connecting multiple devices to your home LAN. For privacy ISP gear prevents customers from seeing each other.
Business customers with multiple IP addresses and static settings are typically routed. The ISP’s router and customer’s router talk to one another. If the company uses multiple ISP their router is also responsible for controlling traffic flow.
In order to share an internet connection a router is needed to manage the LAN and transfer data between the LAN and the ISP’s Network. In some instances the router includes’ a modem allowing the router to be connected directly to the physical ISP network. In other cases the router’s WAN interface is Ethernet allowing it to connect to a separate modem. I prefer using a modem/router combo. This makes accessing modem stats easier than using separate devices and also typically lower power consumption.
If you only need to connect a single device simply plug it into the modem. But in that case you are probably not reading this paper. If you want to use multiple devices you need a router to share the ISP connection. Using a router creates a clear demarcation between LAN and WAN simplifying troubleshooting. LAN services continue to operate even if the WAN connection is lost. The router market is extremely competitive. New routers can be had for less than $50 US and used high end devices go for short money on eBay.
Figure 4 TP-Link TD-8817 ADSL2+ Router
The goal of using a router is to share your ISP connection with multiple computers. Each device needs an IP address. These addresses can be manually configured by the user or automatically by the router. There are two addresses used on the LAN. The MAC address is hard coded into the Ethernet interface and the IP address is used for upper level communication.
Each interface (wired or wireless) has a unique 48-bit MAC address built into hardware. This allows the device to be uniquely addressed. This address is not the same as the IP address.
Excerpt from Assigned Ethernet numbers:
Ethernet hardware addresses are 48 bits, expressed as 12 hexadecimal digits (0-9, plus A-F, capitalized). These 12 hex digits consist of the first/left 6 digits (which should match the vendor of the Ethernet interface within the station) and the last/right 6 digits which specify the interface serial number for that interface vendor.
These high-order 3 octets (6 hex digits) are also known as the
Organizationally Unique Identifier or OUI.
These addresses are physical station addresses, not multicast nor
broadcast, so the second hex digit (reading from the left) will be even, not odd.
Device manufactures obtain OUIs from IEEE. Each chip is assigned a unique value consisting of the OUI and a serial number allocated from the last three octets. Three octets yield: 16,777,215 values, so the OUI lasts a long time. When the manufacturer exhausts the allocation they need to go back to IEEE and purchase another OUI. Since the first three octets are assigned to the chip manufacturer it is possible to verify who made the chip by looking up the OUI on the IEEE’s web site.
ARP (address resolution protocol) is used to discover which MAC address is associated with a specific IP address. Reverse ARP is used to determine the IP address assigned to a specific MAC address.
The choice for most residential networks is to configure the LAN using RFC 1918 private addresses. By using private addresses and network address translation (NAT) a virtually unlimited number of computers are able to share a single ISP IP address. Being private the address pool can be used and reused multiple times conserving scarce IPv4 Addresses and eliminates the need to pay for multiple public addresses.
The IP address is bound to the physical MAC address. This allows higher level protocols to utilize the IP address while lower level networking uses the MAC address.
There are two ways to configure IP setting on LAN devices, statically and dynamically. Each has benefits and limitations.
The pros and cons of static allocation on the LAN are much the same as on the WAN. Static assignment requires IP parameters: address, subnet mask, gateway address, and DNS addresses be manually configured on the device. If the LAN is using a mix of static and dynamic addresses it is important to pick a static address outside the range used by DHCP but within the subnet. If not a computer is configured statically may use the same address as another computer configured via DHCP. This results in an address collision which will prevent both devices from communicating.
Our router’s base address is 192.168.2.1. We configured the DHCP server pool to issue a maximum of 32 addresses beginning with 192.168.2.2 with a subnet mask of 255.255.255.0. Static addresses are assigned beginning at 192.168.2.100 and up with the same subnet mask. This keeps all addresses within the subnet without interfering with each other.
In most operating systems the default is automatic network address configuration. This can be changed to a static manual configuration if desired. In Windows DNS may be set statically even if the IP address is configured dynamically. This can be a handy troubleshooting tool when debugging DNS issues.
This is the default behavior of most operating systems. When the computer detects it is connected to a network, either wired or wireless, it searches for a DHCP server. The DHCP server in the router responds to the request and assigns each machine an appropriate IP address and other settings. Once the PC is configured it is able to communicate. The address is leased to the client. Prior to lease expiration the client attempts to renew it. Under normal conditions this is successful and the lease never expires and the IP address remains the same. If client is off network for extended period of time the lease will expire. Next time the computer connects it may receive different IP address. This behavior depends on whether or not the DHCP server remembers which MAC addresses have been seen recently.
Figure 5 Windows IP Configuration
For some devices, such as servers, dynamic addressing is inconvenient. There are two ways to maintain a persistent IP address. We have already discussed static assignment, another technique is MAC reservation. The specifics vary by router but what you are doing is using the DHCP server to bind the device IP address to its MAC address. As long as MAC address does not change the device is always assigned the same IP address. This is more convenient than setting addresses manually on each device but achieves the same effect.
A down site of MAC reservation is if you change the router LAN addresses will be once again be randomly assigned. For our LAN I statically assign the address for “servers” and home automation gear. I let the router dynamically assign addresses to “client” devices such as: PCs, laptops, and cell phones.
Most residential ISPs restrict customer to a single IP address. Small size of the IPv4 address (32-bits) space means addresses are in short supply. ISPs often charge extra if more than one address is needed. This creates a quandary; how to cost effectively connect multiple hosts to the internet? The most common workaround is Network Address Translation (NAT) using private IP addresses. IETF RFC 1918 reserves three blocks of IP addresses guaranteed not used on the internet. Because these addresses are not used on the public internet they can be reused multiple times.
Combining NAT, more properly Network Address Port Translation since both address and port number are modified, and RFC 1918 private addresses allow a virtually unlimited number of computers to share an internet connection even though the ISP only provided a single IP address. NAT provides translation between private addresses on LAN side and the single public address issued by the ISP.
Internal LAN traffic proceeds normally; NAT is not required for local traffic between computers on the LAN. When a request cannot be serviced locally it is passed to the NAT router, called a gateway. The router modifies the packet by replacing private address with public address issued by the ISP and if needed changes the port number to support multiple sessions and calculates a new checksum. Router sends modified packet to remote host as-if-it-originated-from-the-router. When reply is received router converts address and port number back to that of the originating device calculates the new checksum and forwards it to the LAN. NAT router tracks individual sessions so multiple hosts are able to share a single address. As far as internet hosts are concerned the entire LAN looks like a single computer.
NAT requires a fair amount of bookkeeping, changing IP and port addresses, and then computing new packet checksum. Routers have no trouble keeping up with WAN connections of a few megabits per second. If you are blessed with fast broadband connection say 100 Mbps or faster make sure the router is up to the task.
NAT translation table size limits the maximum number of simultaneous sessions a router is able to maintain. This limit does not affect normal internet usage. However when Peer-to-Peer (P2P) protocols are used the large number of simultaneous sessions may overwhelm a low-end router.
NAT blocks remotely originated traffic. It functions as a de facto incoming firewall because the router does not know where to forward packets that originates outside the LAN unless specifically programmed with port forwarding rules.
The way File Transfer Protocol (FTP) allocates ports causes problems with NAT. To NAT an outbound FTP session appears to originate from the remote server, rather than internal on the LAN. As a result NAT prevents the transfer. Routers know about this behavior so use of default FTP ports is not a problem. It becomes an issue if you change FTP ports from default 20/21 to some other value.
To learn more read: Active FTP vs. Passive FTP, a Definitive Explanation.
As useful as NAT is it is also controversial. It breaks the end-to-end internet addressing paradigm. NAT maintains state information. If it fails session recovery is not possible. It interferes with server functionality and IPsec VPNs.
This is not to discourage use of NAT as it is very powerful technique. But NAT should be seen for what it is, a short-term workaround to minimize effects of IPv4 address shortage, not a permanent extension to internet technology. For more information see RFC 2993 Architectural Implications of NAT.
Local devices on the LAN are able to communicate directly with one another, a router is not required. However if a device has a packet destined for an off LAN device it forwards the packet to the gateway. The gateway router decides how to deliver packets that travel outside the LAN. Since only a single connection exists between our network and the ISP routing is trivial. The router simply forwards all non-local packets to the ISP’s edge router. The ISP router in turn determines how best to forward the packet.
The DNS (domain name system) allows access to internet hosts by name rather than IP address. Name resolution for local devices is performed by NetBIOS over IP. Windows maintains a list of local computer names. It is also possible to manually define names by placing entries in the Hosts file on the computer to override other name resolution. If Windows cannot resolve a host name locally it assumes it is a remote host and makes a DNS request of the router. Residential routers typically do not actually implement a DNS resolver; rather it simply passes the request to the ISP’s DNS nameserver.
When a PC connects to the LAN one of the pieces of information configured by DHCP is the DNS server address. When a PC needs to look up a host address it sends the request to the router. The router in turn figures out which DNS server to use. ISPs typically implement multiple DNS server for redundancy. If the primary DNS resolver goes down the router will attempt to use the secondary server.
Normally DNS is provided by your ISP. However, any DNS server can be used to translate URLs to IP addresses. If you chose not to use the DNS provided by your ISP you have two option use a public DNS server or run your own. There are a number public DNS servers of which Google is probably the most widely known. The other option is to run your own DNS resolver. I’ve used TreeWalk for many years but it appears the site no longer exists. Currently I’m using the DNS server provided by our ISP.
There is a downside of using a different DNS server. Many larger ISPs have special arrangements with CDN (content delivery network) providers. The role of CDN is to improve streaming performance by locating caching media servers near the respective ISP. If you are not using DNS provided by your ISP may take a hit on multimedia performance since your DNS server is not privy to those special arrangements.
The router includes a stateful inspection firewall. This provides another layer of security by observing inbound and outbound traffic and dropping nonconforming packets.
UPNP is an outgrowth of PC plug and play experience. UPNP is designed to automatically configure local network devices and firewall rules. As this paper should make clear configuring a LAN can be a daunting task requiring user to be conversant with network terminology and concepts. UPNP provides automatic discovery and when needed requests firewall/router configuration changes.
Unfortunately UPNP makes no provision for security so one has no knowledge or control over malicious devices attempting to gain unauthorized access to the internet. If you are unfamiliar with network configuration and confident PCs have not been compromised then UPNP is very convenient. On the other hand if you are comfortable configuring network devices doing so manually improves security. We leave UPnP disabled in the router.
The router implements multiple QoS functions to make optimum use of limited WAN bandwidth. If packets arrive faster than they are able to be delivered QoS places high priority packets at the head of the list. It is important to keep in mind QoS does not improve capacity it simply determines winners and losers. In a bandwidth limited environment that can often improve the user experience but it does not magically create more capacity.
I had been using the free Kiwi Syslog server and client to store and display router and time server stats. Unfortunately our current router does not support syslog so we no longer use a syslog server.
Routers typically include a number of remote management features. They assist in troubleshooting but do impact security. Below are the most common management functions.
Internet control management protocol (ICMP) is a suite of tools used to trouble network problems. For our purposes the most useful is Ping. Ping sends a small packet to the remote host and waits for a response. This is an easy way to verify remote host is up and running. It is a good idea to enable router to respond to ICMP. In addition may need to contact your ISP to have them enable ICMP within their network. Some ISPs disable support for ICMP making troubleshooting more difficult.
SNMP (simple network management protocol) is a widely used management scheme for large networks. SNMP can be configured to provide read only access to configuration data or read/write enabling remote management. SNMP uses a MIB (management information base) to interpret status and remotely manage a device. SNMP is not typically used on small networks. If SNMP is not being used disable the feature, or if device does not allow SNMP to be disabled, at least change the default read-only and read-write community strings. The community string acts as a password so the device will only responds to authorized queries. Default community strings are often public/private.
TR-069 CPE WAN Management Protocol is a Broadband Forum spec to facilitate ISP management of end user devices. If the router is supplied or configured by your ISP this feature is probably enabled and you will not be able to turn it off. If you are managing the router yourself turn off this feature unless you have shared access password with your ISP.
Running a public server behind NAT requires the router forward incoming connection requests to the appropriate server. By default incoming connection requests are discarded because router does not know which host on the LAN to forward them. The router acts as de facto inbound firewall. Port forwarding configures the router to accept an inbound connection request, to say port 80, and forward to the web server. To the remote host the server looks like it is using the public IP address supplied by the ISP, when in fact web server is on a private address hidden from the internet.
Operational tip - Most Residential NAT routers do not perform WAN Loopback. This prevents access to local public server by its URL or public IP address from within the LAN. Server must be accessed by its LAN machine name or LAN IP address. When a server is accessed by its public IP address within the LAN the router forwards the request to the internet. It does not realize host is local. End result is packet never reaches the server.
If local access by DNS name or public address is important add the name/address information to Windows Host file. The Host file performs static name translation service invoked prior to DNS. If the requested host name is found in Hosts file Windows will use that address and not query DNS.
Remote hosts use DNS to map URL to server’s IP address. DNS assumes server configuration is static and changes only rarely. This poses a problem for residential customers with dynamic address allocation since server address may change suddenly without notice. Several services have sprung up to address this issue. Dynamic DNS services either run a small application on the router or on server to detect IP address change. When the address changes the Dynamic DNS service is notified. This is not a perfect solution since there can be significant delay between address changes and when new address is available. However for casual residential users it works well enough.
Most residential broadband ISPs allocate a single IP address per account. This causes problems running multiple servers of the same type. For example when running a web server, by default incoming requests are directed to port 80, making it impossible to run two web servers on a single IP address using the well-known port number. A workaround is to use a different port number for one of the web servers. If you are the only one accessing the server this is not a concern since you are aware of the non-standard port and can easily specify it in the browser.
Where this becomes a problems is with a public server. In that case users have no way to know they need to use a nonstandard port to access the server. Many DynamicDNS services have provisions to redirect requests to the alternate port.
Great care should be taken when running public servers. If an attacker is able to exploit a weakness in the server they gain access to the entire LAN. Once in control of a compromised server they are free to attack other machines on the LAN. We use a hosting service to minimize security risk rather than run a public server locally.
If a single internet connection is not adequate one option is obtain addition connections and use bonding or a load balancing router. As with all engineering decisions there are tradeoffs.
Bonding combines multiple ISP connections into a single pipe with the effective speed of the sum of each pipe and a single IP address. Bonding requires the cooperation of the ISP. While the effective speed is doubled (assuming two equal speed links) it does not have much effect on latency since data is split between each connection
Load balancing is performed by a router with multiple WAN connections. As each outbound LAN request hits the router it picks the least used connection. From the internet perspective each connection has its own IP address so it simply looks like two independent links. The advantage of load balancing is it does not require the ISP to do anything. Even though each individual session is limited to the speed of whichever link it is assigned traffic is spread evenly over all links so effective internet speed is increased.
In a SOHO network LAN performance is rarely a speed determinate. Speed is typically limited by first-mile WAN connection. It can be a challenge teasing out various components of end-to-end performance to see if ISP link is working as advertised. The first step is to determine the bit rate being delivered by the ISP. In the case of ADSL this is a matter of looking at modem status and determining download and upload bit rate.
IP transmission splits data into 1500 byte chunks called packets (1-byte = 8-bits). Some of the 1500 bytes are used for network control so are not available for user data. TCP/IP uses 40 of the 1500 bytes for control. NOTE: this analysis assumes use of maximum size packets. Since overhead is fixed using smaller packet size incurs a higher percentage overhead. With 40-bytes reserved for control out of every 1500-bytes sent only 1460 are available for data. This represents 2.6% overhead.
Some ISPs, typically phone companies, use an additional protocol PPPoE to transport DSL data. This is an adaptation of PPP used by dialup ISPs. Telco’s like PPPoE because it facilitates support of third party ISPs as mandated by FCC. PPPoE appends 8-bytes to each packet increasing overhead to 48-bytes reducing payload to 1452. Where PPPoE is used overhead is increased to 3.2%.
Most DSL ISPs use IP over ATM (asynchronous transfer mode) (AAL5). ATM was designed for low latency voice telephony. When used for data it adds significant overhead. ATM transports data in 53-byte Cells of which only 48 are data the other 5 used for ATM control. Each 1500-byte packet is split into multiple ATM cells. A 1500-byte packet requires 32 cells (32 x 48 = 1,536 bytes). The extra 36=bytes are padded, further reducing ATM efficiency. 32 ATM cells require modem transmit 1,696 bytes of which only 1452 carry payload. Where ATM/PPPoE is used overhead is increased to 14.4%.
TCP/IP overhead 2.6% efficiency 97.4%
TCP/IP/PPPoE overhead 3.2% efficiency 96.8%
TCP/IP/PPPoE over ATM overhead 14.4%, efficiency 85.6%
NOTE: This is best-case speed based on packet overhead only. Errors, transmission delays, etc. will reduce speed from this value. The higher the speed the more impact even modest impairments have on throughput.
First Light DSL does not use PPPoE saving that overhead. Because speed is not capped like typical ILEC sync speed varies between 7.2 and 8.2 Mbps depending on line conditions. A sync speed of 8.0 Mbps down and 1 Mbps up yielding best case transfer of 6.9 Mbps down and .86Mbps up.
Figure 6 DSL Speed
If you want to connect more than one computer to the internet you need a Local Area Network (LAN). LANs are useful for much more than just sharing your internet connection. Having a LAN allows computers to access shared resources such as a printer and files. Local resources remain accessible even if you lose internet access. Wi-Fi and Unshielded Twisted Pair (UTP) Ethernet dominate the SOHO market.
Creating a LAN can be as simple as enabling Wi-Fi on your router or as complex as installing hundreds of feet of Ethernet cable and dozens of jacks. Our LAN consists of an Access Point located on the second floor and 24 Ethernet jacks sprinkled throughout the house and office. The DSL router and Ethernet switch connect to an Ethernet patch panel located in the basement near my office.
Residential routers include at least one Ethernet port. Some incorporate a built in Ethernet switch to provide multiple ports. The router provided by our ISP is a single port router. This is not an issue for us as we need a large number of Ethernet ports so we use a 16-port Gig Ethernet switch.
Performance tip – Using a single wide switch is advantageous from a performance standpoint rather than cascading multiple switches. While cascaded switches are transparent doing so limits speed between switches to that of the intervening link. In a wide switch traffic between ports travels over the much faster internal switch fabric.
Electrically UTP Ethernet is a point-to-point topology. Each Ethernet Interface must be connected to one and only one other Ethernet Interface. Hubs and Switches are used to regenerate Ethernet signals allowing devices to communicate with one another. Due to their tremendous performance advantage switches have entirely replaced hubs.
The carrier sense multiple access – collision avoidance (CSMA/CA) scheme originally used by Ethernet places a limit on the number of wire segments and how many hubs can be used within a single collision domain. Each device listens for the bus to be idle before it begins to transmit. It is possible multiple devices will transmit at the same time, causing a collision. When that occurs data is corrupted. Transmission is halted and each device waits a random amount of time before attempting to transmit again. Original Ethernet was half duplex, only one device on the network is able to talk at a time, all others are listening.
Ethernet switches operate very differently. The switch examines each arriving packet, reads the destination MAC address and passes it directly to the proper output port. Switches eliminate the collision domain allowing multiple conversations to occur simultaneously. This dramatically increases network performance. A 100 Mbps hub shares 100 Mbps among all devices. With a switch traffic flows between port pairs. A non-blocking 16-port 1Gbps Ethernet switch has a maximum throughput of 16Gbps. This assumes connections are evenly used among the 16 ports each one operating at 1Gbps. Port A is able to talk to port D at the same time Port F is talking to Port B and so forth. Switches enable full duplex communication, computers are able to transmit and receive at the same time. Switches offer a tremendous performance advantage compared to hubs. In a home network switches represent a less dramatic improvement if almost all traffic is to and from the internet rather than between devices on the LAN. In that case the internet connection, normally much slower than the LAN, constrains speed. However if there are local resources such as files and printers on the LAN the Ethernet switch advantage come into play even on small home networks.
When a switch does not know which port to use it floods the incoming frame to all ports, much like a hub. When the device responds the switch learns the MAC address or addresses associated with the port. Once it knows which MAC addresses are associated with each port it only needs to forward frames to that port. The switch also floods all ports with broadcast frames. Switches are transparent to Ethernet traffic, replacing a hub with a switch is simply a matter of swapping out the device.
Ethernet switches come in managed and unmanaged flavors. Managed devices allow the administrator complete control of various parameters, define VLANs and observe traffic etc. An unmanaged switch has no user interface and is simply plugged into the network. Managed switches are overkill in a typical SOHO network. Unmanaged devices are considerably less expensive and operate at lower power reducing energy cost.
Our switch is an interesting hybrid between managed and unmanaged. We use a Netgear ProSafe Plus 16-port Gig switch. It is like an unmanaged switch in that you just connect it to your LAN and it works. The Web Interface allows you to do many of the features of a managed switch while still being priced near that of an unmanaged dumb switch and important for our situation it is the same size. This was critical as I have very limited space to locate the switch.
The features that are of particular value to me are: Port Status, Port Statistics, Mirroring and Cable tester. The switch supports other useful features such as VLANs and QoS that we are currently not using.
Mirroring is handy for troubleshooting as it copies traffic to another port. This allows that port to be used as a monitor to analyze traffic. There is also a built in cable tester able to detect bad cables and estimate distance to the fault.
Figure 7 Ethernet Switch Port Status
This page shows the connect speed of each device. As you can see we have a mix of speeds. Most of the 10 Mbps devices are the home automation controllers; however some are hosts that drop down to 10 Mbps when idle to conserve power.
Figure 8 Ethernet Switch Port Statistics
We have a mix of Cat 5 and Cat5e cabling. The runs are all fairly short but I wanted to make sure the links are working without errors even at 1 Gbps. Much to my relief the switch is reporting zero errors over long period of time.
To make Ethernet easier to use higher speeds are backward compatible. Transceivers Auto negotiate link characteristics to determine speed and whether connection is half or full duplex. Hubs are limited to half duplex as only one device is able to transmit at a time. Switches are full duplex capable of transmitting and receiving at the same time.
Ethernet and Fast Ethernet NIC (computer interface) is configured as uplink port (MDI), Hub or switch as MDI-X. Default configuration assumes MDI port is connected to MDI-X port. One pair of the cable is used for transmit the other for receive. Under normal circumstances devices connect using a 1:1 cable. A mismatch occurs when like devices are connected, say PC to PC or switch to switch. To make this easier hubs/switches have historically had an uplink switch or dedicated uplink port. The uplink port reverses normal TX/RX configuration so another like device can be connected. The same effect can be obtained by using a crossover cable. Crossover cable swaps TX and RX pair at one connector. Recently vendors have adopted Auto-MDI-X to automatically determining remote port type and configure ports automatically eliminating the need for crossover cables, and uplink ports/switch on Ethernet switches. Gig UTP Ethernet and faster uses all four pairs simultaneously for transmit and receive.
With Auto negotiation (Speed/duplex) and Auto-MDI-X (gender) Ethernet has become much more user friendly. All a user needs to do is connect the cable, everything else is automatic.
Until recently Ethernet delivered data but not power. Each device had to provide its own power. For traditional “large” networked devices such as computers this was not an issue. However as more and more low power appliances such as Wi-Fi Access Points and Voice over IP (VoIP) telephones and IoT (internet of things) are deployed the benefit of delivering both data and power over Ethernet cabling became obvious.
IEEE took on the challenge and in 2003 released the PoE specification. PoE provides 13 watts of power per device. For 10 and 100 Mbps Ethernet PoE uses the two unused pair. Gig and higher speed uses all four pair so power has to be injected into the active pairs. Second generation PoE, called PoE plus, increased maximum device power to 25 watts. Third generation 4PPoE increased power to 51 watts and most recently Type 4 to 71 watts.
PoE has been a boom for low powered devices. It also facilitates backup power, as the UPS only needs to feed the PoE Switch (or power injector) rather than be located at every device. Currently I’m remotely powering our Access Point but not using PoE.
UTP is a point to point technology. Cable runs from an outlet located near the device to a port on the Ethernet switch. For maximum performance a single wide Ethernet switch should be used to serve the entire LAN rather than cascading switches. Cascading is transparent to traffic but limits inter switch speed to that of the link connecting the switches. With a single wide switch intra-LAN throughput is dictated by the much higher performance of the internal switch backbone.
Ethernet IEEE 802.3 using UTP (unshielded twisted pair) copper cable is by far the most common LAN technology in use today in the US. In Europe (STP) shielded twisted pair is often used but it much more difficult to terminate. UTP consisting of 8 conductors organized as 4 twisted pairs terminated with 8 conductor modular (8P8C) jacks similar to those used for telephone wiring. The jack is commonly, but incorrectly, referred as an RJ-45 jack. As speed has increased the cable specifications have become more stringent. EIA/TIA 568 structured wiring speciation applies to commercial locations and EIA/TIA 570 is the variant for residential.
Since its inception UTP speed has increased dramatically. Today data centers are using 40G Ethernet. For residential use there are new 2.5 and 5G speed version that operate over existing Cat5e and 6 cabling but by far Gig Ethernet is the most common and cost effective speed for residential use. Ethernet has become so ubiquitous special single pair is being used for industrial automation and real time Ethernet is used for time critical applications.
In general Ethernet UTP cable distance is limited to 100 meters (328 feet). Range extenders can be used for longer distance. Cable distance is typically not a concern for residential users.
As speed and distance increases fiber becomes attractive compared to copper cable. The difficulty with fiber is not so much the cost of fiber itself but termination and the cost of opto-electrical converters needed to connect NICs to fiber. That being said fiber is an ideal way to link buildings as it is immune to lightning and able to transport high speed data much further than copper.
Virtual LANs allow a single physical LAN to interconnect multiple computers while isolating one group from another. Typical use is to create VLAN based on community of interest for example payroll, marketing and engineering. A router is used to interconnect separate groups providing a great deal of control over how data flows across VLAN boundaries.
VLANs are not common for home LANs but may become more so if internet services are delivered by multiple service providers, perhaps one for data, another for IP based TV (IPTV), and yet another offering Voice over IP (VoIP).
Ethernet is designed such that one and only one path exist between any two endpoints. If multiple paths exist switches are unable to determine how to forward frames. Spanning Tree protocol was developed to address the problem of multiple paths in complex networks. The protocol detects duplicate paths and turns off redundant ports. Spanning Tree requires managed Switches – low cost unmanaged switches do not implement the protocol. Spanning Tree is typically not an issue in simple SOHO LANs.
Great strides have been made creating high performance low cost wireless LANs. RF technology is at its best where mobility is of paramount importance with bandwidth less so. Wi-Fi radios operate in the unlicensed Industrial Scientific Medical (ISM) band. Wi-Fi popularity has a down side. As more devices attempt to use the limited frequency allocation interference problems increase. Government regulators are addressing interference by designating more bandwidth for unlicensed use. Standards bodies are working to facilitate graceful coexistence between various devices.
IEEE 802.11 radios operate in two modes ad hoc peer-to-peer and infrastructure. Infrastructure mode requires one or more Access Points to bridge wireless network to wired network. Depending on size and type of building construction a site may require multiple Access Points. Ah-hoc mode allows two or more Wi-Fi devices to communicate directly without needing an Access Point. Most Wi-Fi communication makes use of Access Points.
Many residential routers include a Wi-Fi Access Point. Ours does not and even if it did the location of the router is not ideal for Wi-Fi use. We use a standalone Netgear WN802Tv2 Access Point. It is an 802.11n 2.4 GHz Access Point connected to a port on the Ethernet switch. This was a Wi-Fi upgrade we made several years ago and coverage throughout the house and nearby yard is excellent.
There is some confusion as to these two entities. The Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE) develops multiple standards. The two most relevant for this paper are 802.3 Ethernet and 802.11 Wireless LAN. Interested parties submit a PAR (project authorization request) if approved the activity is assigned a project code. The first Wireless LAN was denoted as 802.11, the second as 802.11a and so forth. When the end of the alphabet is reach the sequence restarts with a two letter code aa, then ab, ac etc. This works well internally for project tracking but as a marketing name leaves much to be desired.
The success of various IEEE 802.11 wireless standards has encouraged many vendors to enter the market. The Wi-Fi Alliance works to insure interoperability between different vendors and promote use of Wireless LANs. The result is that wireless IEEE 802.11 networks are often referred to as Wi-Fi. Recently the alliance has begun branding various version of the wireless specification with a single increasing number. This is much less confusing for the average consumer then multiple noncontiguous letter designations.
As is the case with Ethernet, IEEE 802.11 Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN) performance has dramatically improved over the years.
Due to the way over-the-air transmission operates real world transfer speed is limited to less than half the raw transmission speed and often significantly lower. However advances in wireless technology make it the network technology of choice in many instances.
Wireless LANs are inherently less secure then wired. An intruder does not require a physical connection, but can eavesdrop some distance away. The original 802.11 designers were aware of this and incorporated Wireless Equivalent Privacy (WEP) into the specification. Unfortunately almost immediately security researchers found critical weakness with WEP and shortly thereafter hacking tools became readily available making WEP virtually useless. As an interim measure the Wi-Fi alliance developed WPA that could be retrofit to existing hardware. IEEE developed a comprehensive security standard Wi-Fi Protected Access 2 (WPA2). WPA2 using AES-CCMP is the preferred privacy implementation. Only use WPA or WPA2-TKIP if equipment does not support WPA2 AES-CCMP. WEP should never be used.
In 2016 security researchers found a weakness in WPA2 nicknamed: KRACK (Key Reinstallation Attack). There are some software patches that reduce the severity of this attack. The Wi-Fi Alliance has announced a new encryption protocol WPA3.
In a commercial setting WPA2 if often used with RADIUS (remote authentication dial-in user service) to uniquely identify each user. That is typically not an option for home users. A simpler method uses a preshared key (PSK). With PSK the Access Point and each client have a secret password installed for mutual authentication. WPA3 implements Simultaneous Authentication of Equals (SAE) that is more robust then the preshared key mechanism used with WPA2.
There are many key generation utilities available to simplify creating long security keys. Wireless keys need to be significantly stronger than a typical end user password. An attacker is able to capture wireless traffic at their leisure and then use dictionary attack or brute force methods to discover the key. This is very different than trying to login to your account online since most implementations lockout the account after a few invalid attempts.
To improve security do not used the default network name (SSID), create your own. This prevents an attacker from quickly running through a list of previously cracked passwords/SSID combinations.
WPS was designed to make it easier for home users to configure multiple Wi-Fi devices using a preshared key. Creating a long key and configuring Wi-Fi parameters can be a daunting task for the typical user. Unfortunately, as was the case with WEP, security flaws have been discovered in WPS implementation. The Wi-Fi alliance has tightened testing of WPS but to be on the safe side it is best to disable this feature and manually configure devices.
Under normal conditions each AP will broadcast its name, called the SSID. This broadcast is what is used to display available networks on your computer or phone. The client in turn selects one of the available networks and uses its SSID to request it be associated with that network. It is possible to turn off SSID broadcast and some folks argue it improves security however that is not true. If SSID broadcast is disabled the SSID must be added to the client manually to allow it to connect. The client in turn has to broadcast the SSID in effect asking - hey is there an Access Point nearby with this name? All an attacker needs to do is wait for someone to connect in order to learn the SSID of the Access Point.
If a single AP does not cover the intended location you can install multiple AP and set them to the same SSID. As the client moves around it will track the signal strength of the various Aps and automatically switch to the strongest.
Wi-Fi radios operate in unlicensed bands so interference can be a problem, especially in congested urban areas. The radios must be certified as compliant with the specification but users do not need an FCC license to operate the equipment. Interference is the result of other Wi-Fi radios, non-Wi-Fi radios operating in the same band such as Bluetooth or wireless phones and unintentional radiators such as microwave ovens. Wi-Fi operates in three bands 2.4GHz and 5GHz are the most common 801.11ac operates in the 60 GHz band for extremely high speed but short range communication. The 2.4GHz band is by far the most popular but it is also the most crowded. While there are many 2.4 GHz channels Wi-Fi uses a much wider channel so there are only three non-overlapping Wi-Fi channels. In general when operating at 2.4 GHz it is best to use channels 1, 6, or 11 for optimum performance.
Wi-Fi alliance has published numerous whitepapers on the subject. They are working with various standards bodies to make devices more aware of their RF environment by probing for other radios operating in the vicinity. That knowledge is used to set operating channel and transmit power to minimize interference.
Given the tremendous popularity of this technology governments are working to increase frequency allocation for unlicensed radio use. As radios get smarter and frequency allocation increase interference should become less of a problem.
Figure 9 2.4GHz Wi-Fi Channels
Figure 10 5GHz Wi-Fi Channels
Ethernet and Wi-Fi are the dominant LAN technologies. The cost of installing network wiring is modest if done when the structure is being built. The situation is more difficult for existing building. The cost and disruption to retrofit a LAN can be significant deterrent. Various “no new wire” initiatives minimize impediments to home networking. These initiatives typically operate at lower speed than wired Ethernet but have the advantage of not requiring additional wiring.
It is a testament to Ethernet’s popularity all these alternatives all use modified Ethernet frames, adapted to the physical medium, making it easy to bridge to standard Ethernet equipment.
Bluetooth is optimized for low power short range peripheral connection such as wireless headsets. Since Bluetooth operates in the crowded 2.4GHz band care needs to be taken so Bluetooth and Wi-Fi do not degrade one another. While Bluetooth can be used to create a network, it is more commonly used to attach peripherals wirelessly.
Home Phoneline Network uses telephone wiring to create bridged Ethernet LAN operating at a maximum speed of 320 Mbps. This allows computers to connect wherever a phone jack exists. The specification allows analog telephone, DSL, and LAN to coexist on a single pair of ordinary telephone wire. Like DSL HomePNA take advantage of unused capacity of copper wire to create a network.
PNA uses a slightly modified Ethernet packet. This makes HomePNA look like ordinary Ethernet to software. HomePNA equipped computers cannot connect to UTP Ethernet directly, a bridge is needed to rate match between the two networks and deal with minor signaling differences. This allows HomePNA and Ethernet devices to act as if they were connected to the same LAN.
HomePNA never really took off so finding gear can be difficult. There are numerous Ethernet extenders that are able to use existing voice grade telephone twisted pair. Many of these use VDSL2 chipsets allowing point to point Ethernet connections over several thousand feet. I used a pair of StarTech VDSL2 Ethernet range extenders to help a friend bring their LAN out to a barn a couple of hundred feet away from the house.
HomePlug initiative provides high-speed network device that plug into ordinary AC receptacles at speeds up to 200 Mbps. The Home Plug Alliance is the clearinghouse for power line networking products.
MoCA is popularizing an interesting technology that utilizes TV coax wiring to deliver Ethernet at up to 2.5 Gbps. A competing ITU-T standard G.hn is getting international traction and hits the2 Gbps range.
Many homes built in the last few decades have RG6 coaxial cable feeding multiple TV outlets but are not equipped with Category rated UTP cable suitable for conventional Ethernet. Verizon is using the technology extensively to eliminate need to run both coax and UTP Ethernet to set top boxes when installing FIOS.
There are many advantages of running your own server. Having an always on computer on your LAN makes it easy to back up PCs and provide a number of other network services.
We use a server for the following services:
1) Windows peer to peer files sharing
2) Destination for automatic PC backup
3) NTP clock synchronization
4) Private web server
5) Web based access to home IoT devices
I bought up an off lease ThinkPad T420 laptop upgraded to Win 10 Pro on eBay. First thing I did was clone the HDD to and SSD to replace the rotating media. Then I ordered a drive adapter to use a 2TB 2.5” hard drive in the DVD slot as a data drive. I’ve been working with computers for decades and the ability to have 2TB in such a small form factor blows me away. Copied the data from the old server and enabled sharing of specific directories.
As with the other Win 10 systems I turned off as many of the tracking options as possible and used Open-Shell to replace the tablet style start menu with a Win 7 look alike.
In the past when I upgraded my desktop PC I would recycle it as a poor man’s server. The downside of using a desktop as a server is it draws about 80 watts. I’ve been happy with the various ThinkPad’s I’ve owned over the years so decided to use a laptop as the server. This reduced AC power consumption to about 20 watts.
New Hampshire has relatively expensive electrical power about $.20 per kWh. An 80 watt load running 24/7 consumes about 2 kWh per day or 57.6 kWh a month. At $.20 a kWh the server costs $11.52 a month, using a laptop reduced cost to $2.88 per month.
I found a nifty utility called Input Director that enables keyboard and mouse sharing. You configure Input Director to specify where, relative to your main display, the slave device resides. I only have one slave located to the left of the main LCD. Moving the mouse to the left side of the screen switches peripheral input control to the laptop. I find this much more convenient than using the KVM. Being a laptop when the screen is blanked wakeup is virtually instantaneous. The only downside I’ve found is you have to make sure the mouse is back on the main screen if you reboot the slave or you lose the ability to control the main computer.
A nice feature compared to using a KVM is you can copy stuff to the clipboard to move it between computers.
Prior to Win 10 Microsoft used an election process to select the master browser. The master browser collects information about machines on the LAN. PCs on the LAN hold an election process to select which machine will be the master browser. If that machine is shut down the lack of a master browser is detected and anther election is held. This software was built on SMBv1 (server message block) which has security vulnerabilities. SMVv1 has been depreciated and the master browser has been replaced with WS-Discovery.
One of the advantages of having a LAN is to facilitate file sharing. Files can be shared directly between PCs or by using a dedicated file server. Access is organized by workgroup. In a small LAN all machines typically belong to a single workgroup, such as HomeLAN. Once properly configured users are able to browse network shares, as easily as if they were physically on the local machine. Commonly used shares can be mapped as a virtual drive providing seamless integration.
We mainly use server shares for automated backup. Software running on each workstation periodically backs up files to the server. That way if one of the workstations fail or become infected the system can be rebuilt with minimal loss of data.
I had a terrible time getting file sharing to work reliability with Win 10. Randomly share discovery would fail. If I typed the server’s address into network in File Explorer shares were accessible. Regardless of whether or not shares were accessible media files were always visible, so network discovery was working. Tried all the tips I ran across on the internet to no avail.
A workaround I discovered is to do a Network Reset on the server. That fixes the sharing problem but also resets the network stack to DHCP so the address of the sever changes. Early I simply reconfigured the server to static after the network reset but on one occasion that also broke sharing. My solution was to configure MAC reservation in the router. That way when I reset the server to fix the sharing problem, it will obtain the same dynamic IP address. This works but I find it frustrating that Microsoft broke something as basic as peer-to-peer file sharing that had been working just fine in previous versions of the OS.
Client PCs are automatically backed up to the server using Acronis True Image Home. Backup is set on a weekly schedule so at worst a week’s worth of work is lost. This has come in handy when we had a disk crash. Offline backup is covered in more detail later.
NIST the US National Institute of Standards and Technology and other organizations maintain public timeservers. This eliminates problem of drifting and inaccurate computer real time clocks. For personal use NIST recommends using NTP Pool Time Servers. Timeservers are extremely accurate; however accessing them via the internet adds potentially several hundred milliseconds of round trip delay. This error is not significant for our purpose and is ignored.
Current generation of Windows PCs have a built in NTP client that is used by default to synchronize the real time clock. This means each PC independently accesses a NTP server somewhere out in the cloud. A more elegant method is to use a time server, running on a local server, and have it in turn synchronize local devices. We use NetTime running on the server and point each non-mobile device to it. This way we are only making a single access to the NTP internet pool and even if we lose internet connectivity devices remain synchronized to one another, abet with more drift due to the server RTC. This is most important for the home automation PLCs as they do not have a built in battery backed RTC. If power is restored they default to junk date/time. From a privacy perspective another benefit of running your own NTP server it that only one access is being made to NTP time severs as opposed to individual access from each device.
The browser home page of each desktop PC points to the personal web server running on the server. This allows relevant information be posted. Server main page consist of links to internal devices such as the home automation servers, weather station and network devices as well as useful external links. I chose Abyss as it is free for personal use. So far the web interface consists of static data but on my TO-DO list is to present some of the home automation data using pretty graphs.
Figure 12 Abyss Server Console
I had resisted moving from Win 7 to Win 10. However with end of support near for Win 7 I decided to bite the bullet and replace my wife and my desktop PCs. I did that at the same time I replaced the server with a laptop mentioned in the previous section.
I purchased a couple of off-lease HP Z230 SFF computers. These were originally Win 7 boxes but the refurbishing service upgraded them to Win 10 Pro. Over the years we have been happy purchasing several year old off-lease commercial computers.
I’m not a fan of the Win 10 touch pad interface so installed Open Shell to deliver a Win 7 type interface.
Figure 13 Open Shell Start Menu
Win 10 seems to be working pretty well, but then I had no problem with Win 7 I only upgrade because security update stop in 2020. One annoying thing I’ve noticed is it now takes many more Mouse clicks to do semi low level stuff. Something as simple as changing the NTP time server from the desktop:
1. Right click Time
2. Click Adjust date/time
3. Settings Left click Related setting – Date, time & regional formatting
4. Setting Left click Related settings – Additional date, time & regional
5. Control Panel\Clock and Region Left click – Date and Time
6. Date and Time Left click – internet Time
7. Date Time Left click – Change Settings
8. Internet Time Setting – enter URL/IP click Update now.
9. internet Time Setting – Click OK
10. Close Date and Time
11. Close Control Panel
12. Close Setting
As with the server I turned off as much of the Windows 10 tracking as possible in Windows 10.
I maintain a dual boot PC: Windows 7 and Ubuntu to do software testing. I reinstalled Win 7 on our existing HP DC7900 SFF PC. Once I had that running and up to date installed Ubuntu in a dual boot configuration.
My laptop is another off lease computer, a Lenovo ThinkPad T520 I purchased several years ago running Win 7 Pro. Since the server is a ThinkPad T420 and desktops are all running Win 10 decided to upgrade my laptop. I had resisted the MS free upgrade but now that Win 7 has reached end of life Microsoft will no longer be fixing security bugs.
I purchased another 240GB SSD and cloned the old drive. That way if the upgrade failed I had a backup. Swapped the drives – so far so good. I ran across several YouTube videos indicating even though the much maligned Microsoft Win 10 free upgrade offer was long gone it will still possible to upgrade.
I downloaded Win 10 from the Microsoft site. You have to option to do an in situ upgrade or create boot media. Since I had just cloned the hard drive I chose in situ. We have a relatively slow DSL connection but everything went fine, took a few reboots but as far as I can tell did not lose anything.
For convenience I always purchase a second laptop power adapter. One stays in the laptop travel bag the other is near my desk so I can plug in the laptop and charge it without having to hunt for the charger.
For presentations I use a Logitech R400. Great remote control and has a built in laser pointer.
A large number of laptops/phones/tablets are lost or stolen daily. Once you have lost possession of your computer an attacker has unlimited time to crack whatever security you have used. If the laptop has sensitive information consider using encryption to protect files, or better yet leave the sensitive files in the office and use remote desktop or Citrix to provide access without the need to save the data locally.
Wi-Fi hotspots normally do not provide over the air security like WPA2. This means non-encrypted traffic is easy to eavesdrop. The worst offender is SMTP/POP protocols since they send login credentials in the clear. If your ISP supports using SSL email use that to protect you privacy when accessing email. If not consider restricting access to over a VPN to protect privacy.
Flash drives are often used to move files around between PCs at meetings. There is always a risk of plugging in an infected drive. Maintain up to date anti-virus software and make sure it is configured to verify removable media.
Our cell phone provider Republic Wireless has an interesting wrinkle on mobile telephony. They are a mobile virtual network operator (MVNO). Whenever the phone is connected to Wi-Fi all traffic: voice, text and internet are transported over Wi-Fi eliminating cellular network usage charges. When not connected to Wi-Fi the phone uses the Sprint 3G/4G-LTE network and roams to Verizon if out of range. Voice and text is unlimited regardless of how the phone connects. Any unused cellular data results in a credit on the next month’s bill. The Wi-Fi first feature requires custom Android firmware so phone selection is limited to a few Motorola Android phones customized by Republic but so far the service has worked out well for us. Since most of the places we frequent have Wi-Fi our cellular data usage is very low resulting in very modest monthly cost. Recently RW began offering phones where their special software runs as an application, eliminating the need to modify the Android firmware, allowing unmodified phones to be used.
The next generation of cell phone technology called 5G is following other communication networks in fully embracing the internet and carrying all services as packet switched data. The other much ballyhooed feature is a massive increase in data capacity. This is mainly limited to millimeter wave bands, that while delivering eye popping bandwidth have very short range and do not penetrate buildings very well. 5G does offer improvements when used on the lower bands and being IP centric blurs the distinction between: voice, data and text. I’m looking to upgrade our phones but plan on waiting a year or so for the smoke to clear on 5G.
Battery life of these spiffy smart phones is significantly shorter than flip phones. In the office I keep a USB cable plugged into the server at my desk. This is convenient and eliminates the need to keep the USB AC charger plugged in. I keep the phone charger in my laptop bag for travel. In the car we use a USB car adapter to keep the phone charged while driving. The cigarette lighter (accessory) socket is turned off when the car is not running but that is not a problem as we don’t leave the phones in the car when we are not there. When camping needing to run the car’s engine to activate the socket is be a problem as the phones need to be charged every day unless they are put into airplane mode. I wired up a cigarette lighter socket to a couple of large alligator clips and a fuse. The adapter can be clipped directly to the car’s battery to recharge the phones. We also carry a rechargeable USB power pack that provides several days of phone power.
Initially I tried purchasing USB cigarette lighter chargers on eBay. I loaded tested the chargers and they failed miserably. None of them delivered the rated current and worse became very hot so I gave up on no-name Chinese charger and purchased a bunch of Anker chargers for myself and family. The USB cable also figures into this. Having a phone with a high current requirement plugged into a small gauge USB cable will substantially increase charge time.
While POTS is ancient technology it is incredibly reliable here in snowy NH. We have lost power multiple times over the years, sometimes for days at a stretch, but we have never lost telephone service. When we switched to a CLEC for DSL got several advanced POTS calling features and unmetered US and Canadian calling, all for less than we were paying previously. Even though free there were two advanced features I had the CLEC turn off, voice mail and call waiting. We have our own answering machine; it is easier pressing a button on the machine to retrieve messages than dialing into the CLEC VM system. The other was Call Waiting; if the phone is busy the person can call back later rather than interrupt an ongoing conversation.
These devices are becoming more common. Being wireless they place additional demands on the Wi-Fi access point.
There are many ways to distribute Radio and Television programs. Internet over the top (OTT) delivery opens up fascinating opportunities for new sources not constrained by distance or even a local presence.
We had been using a WD Live Hub to watch Netflix on our main TV, WD ended support December 1st 2019. I replaced it with a Roku Express media player. It is Wi-Fi only; I prefer Ethernet but as we only have 7Mbps DSL and in a rural area so Wi-Fi congestion is not a problem it works fine.
It is possible to implement a TV server and then distribute programs over your LAN. The Silicon Dust HDHomeRun is probably the best known system. We are OTA (over the air) TV viewers and waiting for the dust to settle on the rollout of ATSC 3.0. This is an enhanced version of digital TV but is not backward compatible with the current standard ATSC 1.0. This means TVs need to implement both ATSC 1.0 and ATSC 3.0 tuners. In addition the ATSC 3.0 spec provides internet integration so lots of complex software on the part of the receiver. The HDHomeRun system looks very interesting but we plan on waiting until it supports ATSC 3.0.
Titan TV is a popular on line TV program guide. You select your location of if you are using over the air or subscribe to cable.
Computers were once billed as the paperless office. This has not happened. On the other hand internet and low cost high quality printers have significantly expanded use of electronic document distribution. This White Paper is a perfect example. It was composed on a computer, uploaded to a web server and is directly viewable on the web or demand printed as needed.
Our printer is an HP 8100 Officejet Pro. The 8100 includes a built in print server allowing it to be directly connected to the LAN. Being a higher end inkjet printer the print heads and ink are separate and it has separate ink cartridges for each color. This reduces the cost per page.
Printing documents on different printers can be a challenge since margins and fonts differ. The Adobe PDF format has become the de facto industry standard for print document formatting.
A Brother P-touch PT-2430PC USB printer is used to print various labels.
A Flatbed scanner converts documents and photographs to digital image files. These files can be faxed or incorporated into documents. Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software converts text images to format understood by word processors.
I prefer using a separate scanner rather than an all in one printer/fax/scanner because the printer is behind my desk and the flatbed scanner is conveniently located on my desk. We are currently using an Epson V550 Photo scanner. It also functions as a poor man’s copying machine allowing scanned images to be directly printed.
My office has a main workstation, test PC running Win 7 and Ubuntu and ability to temporally connect another computer for configuration and test purposes. I did not want to use dedicated I/O for each computer. The solution was to use a KVM (keyboard, video, and mouse) switch. KVM’s have been used in server farms for years to allow single point of control for multiple computers. KVMs are pretty brute force doing hardware switching of peripherals; it doesn’t interact or care about the O/S. I purchased a 4-port Belkin Omni View SE KVM. Port 1 is the main workstation, port 2 is the Win7/Ubuntu test computer, Port 3 is not used and port 4 is for temporary connection to PCs I’m working on. I wired up a set of I/O, network, and power cables to make it easy to temporally connect another PC for test or configuration. That has turned out to be a very handy benefit of using the KVM.
Switching between computers is done via a button on the KVM or a keyboard hot-key sequence. When switching computers the KVM reconnects keyboard, mouse and monitor to the active computer and reconfigures the keyboard and mouse to match their condition prior to being switched away from that computer.
System Boot – The KVM does not emulate the attached device. It simply passes any commands to the devices and remembers recent commands so the device can be reconfigured when switching computers. This causes problems at boot time if the KVM is not switched to that computer. Video defaults to low resolution VGA and the mouse to basic PS/2 mouse. Normally this only occurs after a power failure when PCs are powered up and the KVM set to a different computer.
Video Performance Tip -- Workstations use higher resolution than servers resulting in very high video data rate. This is typically not a problem for KVM itself but requires high quality video cable when used with analog monitor interface. Coax preserves high frequency and minimizes crosstalk between the red, green, blue video signals.
Mouse Compatibility Tip -- Each computer thinks it is directly connected to a keyboard, mouse and monitor. The KVM memorizes commands sent to each device and restores device configuration when user selects a different computer. PS/2 Mice cause problems because there are so many proprietary enhancements. PS/2 mice power up in compatibility mode in order to support basic mouse functionally, even if proprietary mouse driver is not installed. At O/S boot time mouse driver performs a “knock” sequence to determine if a known mouse is attached. If mouse answers correctly driver switches on enhanced mode. This causes problems for KVMs. Unless the KVM has a-priori knowledge of a specific mouse it does not know which commands it needs to store to configure the mouse correctly. This may result in either loss of mouse control or mouse reverting to default mode. This is only a problem when switching between machines. The KVM transparently passes commands from active machine to mouse so in that case the mouse is always be correctly configured.
This problem only affects PS/2 style mice since they do not support hot plug. A USB enabled KVM resets mouse whenever a different computer is selected. The downside if USB enabled KVMs is that it often takes a long time to reconfigure a USB device.
PS/2 Mice – PCs have supported USB mice and keyboards for years. Our KVM only supports PS/2 devices. It is becoming increasingly difficult finding PS/2 compatible mice so I keep a spare on hand just in case.
Monitor Plug and Play – modern CRT and LCD monitors communicate with PC using VESA Display Data Channel (DDC). This allows PC to read monitor characteristics and automatically configure video subsystem. My KVM passes DDC commands but does not emulate the monitor itself. If a PC powers up on an inactive KVM port it thinks it is connected to a non-Plug and Play monitor reverting to low resolution low refresh mode. A workaround for this is to disable monitor plug and play and set resolution and refresh manually. Or always make sure PC is selected by KVM before booting.
Several years ago I set up a portable generator to supply power in the event of an outage. These occur every few years due to massive ice or snow storms. These tend to be statewide outages and we can be without power for a week or more. Our goal is to use the generator a few hours in the morning and again in the evening. This intermittent use means we lose internet access when the generator is not running.
There are three pieces of network gear that need to remain powered: DSL modem/router, Ethernet switch and Wi-Fi access point. All of these devices are powered by small DC wall warts. Seems ridiculous to convert batter power to AC then back to DC to power the devices. So I built a simple DC UPS that powers our network gear directly from a 12 volts SLA battery.
The other important consideration is we require rapid battery recharge time and long run time since the generator will only be operated for short periods of time. A novel feature of my design is rather then building the battery into the UPS I use a car jump pack. That gives us the best of both worlds. The UPS gets a “free” battery and the jump pack is kept fully charged by the battery maintainer in the UPS.
I’ve posted details on my site: DC UPS.
Due to the obnoxious over use of web site ads I’ve started to use the Adblock Plus ad blocker.
It is interesting having my own web site to see the ebb and flow of browser popularity. Below is a recent report of browser preferences at my site.
Figure 16 Web Site 2016 Browser Preference
Key to effective use of the internet is being able to find what one is looking for. Our preferred search engine is Google. But it is disconcerting how much information about Google has amassed about me by using their products.
VPNs provide secure access to web sites and extend the corporate network to telecommuters and business partners. There are two approaches to providing secure remote access: IPsec and SSL.
IPsec developed by the IETF has two protection mechanisms Authentication Header (AH) and Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP) AH authenticates the client’s IP address. ESP encrypts data to prevent eavesdropping. Authentication is performed using internet Key Exchange (IKE).
NAT is very hostile to VPN security because it modifies packet address and checksum. Because NAT is so ubiquitous VPN software has implemented workarounds that are compatible with NAT.
Tunnel mode forces all client traffic through IPsec encrypted tunnel to the corporate LAN. This is the most secure and provides the same logging/management functions as if the employee was physically connected locally. The downside it that all traffic has to be encrypted, carried by the tunnel even if it is not directed towards the corporate LAN. An alternative configuration is split-tunnel. In split-tunnel mode tunnel only carries traffic destined for corporate network. Other traffic flows normally as if tunnel did not exist.
Having employees install IPsec client presents a management challenge. As an alternative some companies are using SSL/TLS to provide a secure connection between remote employees and corporate network. All browsers support SSL as a way to securely log into web sites. While SSL is not as powerful or secure as IPsec it eliminates the need for special client software. This is especially convenient for employees that need to connect to corporate network from multiple computers. Most modern browsers will throw a security nag screen if the site you are trying to access does not support TLS.
E-mail accounts fall into three broad categories: ISP, free third party and corporate. ISPs typically provide an email account as part of the package. However with the proliferation of free email accounts like Gmail, some ISPs are eliminating this feature. ISP email ties your e-mail address to your current ISP. Change ISP or if the ISP gets bought out and changes their domain name your e-mail address changes. Free email services like Google Gmail and Yahoo have become extremely popular. Corporate email accounts, tied to the company domain are the third type of email.
For business purposes or to insure long lasting email identity nothing beats registering your own domain. Once registered e-mail is addressed to you@yourdomain.TLD. Even if you change hosting services you simply transfer the domain to the new provider, e-mail address is unaffected.
Even though I have an internet domain I use my Gmail account as an alternative account. To eliminate the need to log into Gmail I have incoming Gmail forwarded to my domain account. My cell phone is Android based and Google wants to tie everything to your Gmail account.
Having multiple email accounts is a useful troubleshooting tool. If one does not work, try the other and then try to determine the difference between the one that works and the one that does not.
I’ve built multiple home automation devices and most have a web interface and the ability to send email.
For example the greenhouse controller sends out a morning and evening status email, documenting the previous 12 hours. It logs into the ISP SMTP server to send email to my domain email address. The recurring nature of these emails is a great troubleshooting tool. Missing a report becomes the trigger to investigate root cause. It has flagged several problems over the years with my ISP email system and with the DSL router refusing to forward DNS requests. All in all a handy side effect of these periodic emails.
Traditionally email uses an email client, such as Microsoft Outlook or Windows Live Mail. Most free mail services use a browser interface eliminating need for a dedicated email client. Web mail is convenient because email is accessible from any browser equipped PC. I find the web based email user interface is somewhat clunky but adequate for casual use.
Except for web-based mail, e-mail has a sending component, SMTP, and a receiving mailbox, POP. To send mail the client connects to a SMTP (simple mail transfer protocol) mail gateway. SMTP server acts as a relay between e-mail client and POP (post office protocol) mail server. The SMTP server verifies each recipient is accessible and returns an error message if not. SMTP server delivers mail to the appropriate POP server. It works much as a physical post office mailbox. The POP server stores mail temporally. When the e-mail client connects to the POP server it downloads mail and typically removes it from the server. A more sophisticated alternative to SMTP/POP email is IMAP (internet message access protocol).
For cell phone access to my domain based email I played around with the Android email client vs using browser based access. Unless I missed the setting you cannot set up Android to only log into an email account manually on demand. It can only be set up to constantly poll the server or be disabled. Given this limitation I opted to access my domain email using the Android browser rather than the email client.
When upgrading to Windows 10 took the opportunity to switch email client. We had been using Windows LiveMozilla Thunderbird. Migrating to Thunderbird was surprising easy. I needed to export Windows Live address book and messages. Importing the address book was pretty easy. To import messages I needed to download a third party app.I switched to
I configured the email client to use SSL/TLS to access SMTP/POP servers. This has the advantage of providing end to end privacy between the email client and mail server. Without using SSL email credentials are sent in the clear making them vulnerable.
Mail Configuration Tip -- Accessing mail when using multiple clients is difficult. One trick is to have your main computer remove mail from the POP server. The other machines retrieve mail but do not delete messages from the server. When you get back to the main machine it retrieves all intervening messages and removes them from the server.
Security Tip -- Be careful opening e-mail attachments. This is a common method used to spread viruses and Trojans. Configure your anti-virus program to scan email and attachments prior to opening them and quarantine infected mail.
Security Tip – Be aware of Phishing attacks. Sender fakes an email and asks you to log in to update or correct your account. Luckily most attacks are worded so poorly as to make them obvious but hover over the link before clicking and see if it is pointing to the real web site. If in doubt close the email and log into to the site normally rather than use the email link.
Security Tip -- What is not well known is that simply reading e-mail can infect your system. ActiveX controls or VB scripts can be embedded in the body of a mail messages. Reading the message activates the virus.
Privacy Warning – An obnoxious privacy intrusion is the insertion a one-pixel image in HTML mail. When message is read browser has to go to the referenced URL to retrieve it. This allows the sender to monitor when and if mail is read.
When logging into traditional SMTP/POP servers unless they are set up for SSL the user’s credentials are sent in the clear. With a wired connection this is not a huge security issue but it is when using popular Wi-Fi hotspots because traffic is not encrypted so anyone nearby is able to eavesdrop on your email credentials. Because of this and other security considerations most email accounts now require the use SSL to encrypt the session protecting it from eavesdropping. If this is an option be sure to take advantage of it, especially on mobile devices.
Unwanted email (SPAM) is a tremendous problem. Something like 70% of all email messages are SPAM. ISPs and third parties have been waging an antispam battle of years. ISPs have adopted a number of strategies to minimize the problem.
M3AAWG is an industry group promulgating best-practices to reduce spam. Historically SMTP servers accepted anonymous email creating a haven for spammers. ISPs have developed a number of proprietary workarounds over the years to limit spam. Recommendation is to use SSL/TLS to securely access SMTP and POP mail server. Where SSL is not feasible use Port 587 to send email instead of Port 25. Port 587 requires authentication therefor ISPs will not block the port allowing off network access.
Many mail services subscribe Blacklist services such as Spamhaus. Blacklists are databases of Spammers and IP address blocks of residential ISPs. If mail arrives from a blacklisted address it is rejected. MXtoolbox has a handy tool to check if the IP address of your mail server has been blacklisted. It also checks MX records to verify domain DNS records are configured correctly.
Sender Policy Framework (SPF) creates a mechanism to validate the email return address is not forged. SPF adds DNS records indicating which servers are authorized to send email from a specific domain. Before email is accepted email server verifies it originated from an authorized server.
For SPAM that makes it all the way through to email client one can set rules for handling incoming mail by the email client. This can drastically reduce the number of unwanted messages in your in box.
File Transfer Protocol (FTP) is an effective way to transfer large files over the internet. FTP predates HTTP so has kind of lost favor but is still very much alive. My main use of FTP is to make changes to my web site. This paper will be uploaded to my web server using FTP. I use WinSCP for FTP.
While GUIs are all the rage there is a lot to be said for command line interfaces (CLI) and heaven forbid I still need to occasionally work on RS232 gear and need a terminal emulator. PuTTY is my preferred application.
Usenet Newsgroups can be a valuable source of up to date information. Given the incredible number of users it is likely that someone will be able to provide an answer to your question. The down side of unmoderated groups is low signal to noise ratio. One needs to wade through a lot of Spam, inane posts, and flames to find the occasional gem. Many groups have an online FAQ that describes what the group is about to limit off topic posts.
Most ISPs used to include USENET access as part of the service. Due to declining interest in Usenet and legal concerns related to pornography most ISPs are eliminating support for Usenet. If your ISP does not provide Usenet access there are a number of 3rd party services.
Most email services set a maximum file size for email. To send large files I use WeTransfer. It is a free service that lets you send files to one or more recipient. When each recipient downloads the file the sender gets a confirming email.
Adding video and audio capabilities to personal computers back in the early ’90s profoundly changed usage patterns. No longer primarily perceived as a computational tool personal computers were transformed into gateways to all sorts of digital media.
Internet multimedia was hampered by low dialup speed. Broadband eases this chokepoint opening the door to internet delivery of telephone, radio, TV and movies. Currently there are numerous CODECs used to compress and play audio and video. This leads to difficulty in making sure one has the correct CODEC.
Internet delivery is bringing dramatic change to long-standing business models. Prior to the internet media distribution was an expensive proposition that had been mastered by only a few companies. The internet undermines traditional business model by reducing distribution cost nearly to zero. Legacy media players are having a difficult time adapting to change wrought by technology and have been primarily focused on crippling digital delivery. Over time both artists and patrons will learn how to utilize this new distribution model.
Audio and video content owners fear lossless digital duplication of copyrighted works will undermine their business rather than open up new distribution models. DRM (digital rights management) has been controversial for both philosophical and technical reasons. What is the proper balance between rights of copyright holders and patrons desire for unfettered access? Technically DRM implementations have been a disaster. DRM is easily circumvented, caused ill will on the part of consumers, broken backward compatibility, rendered investment in content library worthless and been a PR nightmare due to DRM implementation run amuck.
Back in the early ‘90s digital versions of audio CDs were heralded as a tremendous new storage medium. A CD holds about 700 Mbytes of data, compared to only 1.5 Mbytes for a 3.5” floppy. At the time that seemed like an almost infinite amount of space.
Time marches on. DVDs were developed to allow digital movies be distributed in similar format as audio CDs ultimately displacing VHS videotape. DVDs store 4.7 Gbytes (single layer) of data. This is more than enough to store an entire SDTV (standard definition) movie with room for extra features.
With increased popularity of high definition Television HDTV a media format with more capacity was needed. Blu-Ray 25 GB (single layer) won the battle. HDTV dramatically improves image quality compared to NTSC standard definition TV. That being said standard definition DVDs using component video or HDMI interconnect looks pretty good on HDTV TVs and computer monitors.
Video data is encoded and compressed using MPEG compression. Image is compressed (spatially) and between frames (temporally). Audio is also compressed. Without compression files would be uneconomically large.
An annoying aspect of commercial video content is region coding. Typical DVD player will refuse to play the media unless the region code of the player and DVD agree.
Netflix pioneered snail mail DVD rental. Today they are a major streaming service. Netflix customers can use their PC to access a growing library of on-line titles or use Roku player to watch streaming media on their TV. Image quality is automatically adjusted based of broadband speed. We opted for a WD TV live hub to stream Netflix to our TV. However it no longer supports Netflix so we have purchased a Roku Express media player.
Pluto TV is another up and coming streaming service. It is free with content supported by advertising.
Apple’s ITunes music service has been a popular complement to the IPOD as a way to purchase and play digital music.
MPEG MP3 compression provides near CD-quality audio at 128 kbps, about a tenth the uncompressed data rate. MP3 has become a popular digital music format. We converted all CDs and some records (LP and 78 rpm) to MP3 and store music on file server. This enables any computer on the LAN equipped with an MP3 player to access music library. Near CD quality audio requires 128 kbps; this translates to about a megabyte per minute of music. This results in a large library but well within the reach of a today’s cheap hard drives.
Apple QuickTime was a popular movie-encoding format however it has a number of security limitations so many browser are eliminating support and in 2016 Apple announced end of life.
The Video LAN media player is a popular free multimedia player.
Digital cameras are a fantastic way to quickly capture images and incorporate them into documents or a web page. Cameras typically use some form of removable Flash memory to provide virtually unlimited image storage. Images are captured and compressed in JPEG format dramatically reducing size with minimal loss in quality. Cameras typically support USB file access eliminating the need to pop out the memory card to access pictures.
Being lazy, now that I have a smart phone noticed I rarely use my digital camera. The Phone USB charging cable does double duty allowing easy access to pictures and even the occasional screen shot for troubleshooting. I typically transfer pictures to our internal server for safe long term storage and editing shortly after then are taken.
I work from home so have used one flavor or another of Microsoft Office for years, currently using Office 2010 for documenting editing, spreadsheets, and PowerPoint presentations. I’ve played around with Open Office and LibreOffice a little but as long as I can run my copy of MS Office 2010 I’ll just continue to use it. Not looking to rent an office application or need any of the cloud stuff.
Most of the recent changes to our network have been adding Ethernet drops to support home automation projects. Over the last several years I’ve designed a: greenhouse controller, wood heat controller, window ventilation controller, aquarium controller and most recently an outdoor temperature/humidity logger. They are all built around a CAI networks WebControl web based programmable logic controller (PLC). I also designed a control system for our outdoor lights but it is dumb hardware and does not live on the LAN.
The interested reader is referred to the Writings page for more information about these projects.
Computers are great bookkeeping machines making them ideal for tracking home and business finances.
For annual income tax preparation we use Tax Act software.
Having an always-on server makes it possible to schedule automatic backup insuring backup actually happens. However it is not as secure as offline offsite backup. With online backup a software attack or power anomaly may destroy all copies of the data. Even with off line backup if all copies are in the same location they may be destroyed in case of fire or flood. Optimum backup strategy consists of on line and off line backup with off line data stored at a different location. It all depends on how valuable is the data and what is the impact of its loss. I prefer managing my own data so I am not a fan of cloud storage.
One of the benefits of having a server is to provide automatic backup. We use Acronis True Image backup utility. It has the capability to backup only user data or create a complete disk image that can be used to do a system restore the system if the HDD crashes.
Backups are scheduled automatically insuring data is safely duplicated. Use of incremental backup saves only data that has changed since the last backup reducing amount of disk space needed. Even so with modern huge drives the amount of data being backed up can be significant. The main reason I upgraded to a Gig Ethernet switch was to speed up backups.
A downside to keep in mind is if one of the machines on the LAN becomes compromised it is possible the backup shares will be attacked.
External USB hard drives are an ideal way of providing off line backup. They can be disconnected when not in use protecting them from lightning strikes and hardware failures.
Our current off line backup is a WD My Book 4TB USB drive. This is twice the capacity of the server drive so should be good for several years. I set up the drive to back up the server an also each desktop. This necessitates physically connecting the drive to each system’s USB port. I try to be religious doing this to minimize risk of data loss in the event of a hardware failure. The server has a complete system image of each desktop allowing a crashed system to be recovered. When the drive is connected to individual computers it only backs up user data not the entire drive. User data backup provides a more convenient way to access specific files then the incremental disk image.
In an ideal word off line file backups are stored in a separate location in case the building is destroyed. So far I have not gone to that extreme.
One of the things I try to do is create an as-purchased image backup of each computer. This makes it easy to restore the computer to as purchased condition in case of problems or when repurposing the machine, say from a workstation to server or if I need to give the PC away and want to make sure it does not contain any personal data. The Maxtor One Touch USB 500 GB we had been using for several years reached capacity. I repurposed that drive to store the initial disk image of each PC as they were placed in service. Previously I had stored the initial system backup image as part of other back up data. But on more than one occasion I inadvertently deleted the initial image because I forgot what it was. Keeping the initial image on a separate USB drive dedicated to that purpose prevents this Murphy from occurring and allows each system to be brought back to pristine condition.
CDs and DVD are cheap high capacity means to create off line storage. There is some concern about long-term stability of writeable media. It is unclear how long writable media lasts before data is unrecoverable. However it is likely to be at least tens of years so should not to cause problems as off line backup medium.
Multi Gigabyte USB Flash Drives have become extremely popular over the last few years. They offer the advantage of large, low cost rewriteable removable storage. Removing the drives makes it immune to lightning and power lines surges. I like the Cruzer Flash drives because they have a retractable USB plug rather than an end cap.
I’ve been in this game for a long time and the idea of a 32GB Flash drive or 32GB micro SD card (for our cell phones) for under $10US just blows me away.
Internet connectivity is a double edge sword. Being connected gives one access to the vast resources of the worldwide internet but makes your computer vulnerable to attack. Unfortunately a significant number of talented individuals take delight in wreaking havoc on others.
There is no such thing as perfect security. One must take a cold hard look at how computers are used, how valuable is the information, how attractive a target and ramification of a breach. Security engineering is very different than other forms of engineering. In a typical engineering problem a solution is developed and proper operation verified. Various failure modes are analyzed but there is no need to consider deliberate attack designed to pervert operation.
Having to maintain multiple passphrases is a bugaboo of modern life. Strong passphases should be long enough to thwart brute force attacks, have a mix of words and numbers. For extra points throw in a few punctuation characters.
Interesting YouTube video about choosing strong passwords.
No reputable entity will ask you for your password. If there is a problem with your password you may be issued a new one but you will never be asked to give someone your password. On line passwords are reasonable secure because most accounts will be locked out if more than a few incorrect passphrases are entered. The more significant risks are encrypted transmission and devices that can be attacked offline. In that case attacker is able to record the transaction and perform dictionary attack running through millions of possible passphrase until they find the right one. This type of attack is also a risk if a site is compromised. The attack will often yield user password and the attacker can use them to gain access to the compromised site and if you use the same credential other accounts.
For a computer to recognize authorized user it needs a method to establish entered credentials are valid. This means computer must store the passphrase, or more correctly a hash of the passphrase. As long as computer remains under control of authorized user everything works fine. However if machine is stolen or lost an attacker is able to retrieve hard disk contents and run dictionary attack at his leisure. Security researchers have even found it is possible to obtain valid data from dynamic memory even after it has been powered down for a relatively long period of time. Fogo the convenience of having your computer remember passwords and enter then each time you need to log in.
I’m not a fan of password managers; to me this looks like a single point of failure. If the service is ever compromised so are all your passwords.
Sad to say many security breaches are not the result of compromising technical security barriers. They result from individuals inadvertently giving out privileged information. An attacker typically poses as someone who would normally have legitimate access to the desired information: say a police officer or maintenance technician. If the attacker knows enough background information and lingo they are often able to fool representative into telling them information they are not authorized to access.
This is probably what most people think of when discussing security. This attack has been around since the days of standalone PCs using floppy disks. The first line of defense is staying away from untrustworthy sites and do not connect your system to unknown devices. In the past if I wanted to go to a new site I’d often guess the URL since it is often some variation of company name. This is a dangerous practice since attackers often register common misspelling of popular domain names. To prevent this sort of thing I use a search engine to learn the site name. This does not guarantee site is safe but it reduces risk of fat-fingering a dangerous URL. The other vector that is becoming more common is to embed Virus software in online advertising. Since you have no way to know where that is coming from it is very difficult to protect against. One helpful technique is to use an ad blocker. However sites are increasingly refusing to serve content if they detect use of an ad blocker.
Anti-virus programs have been available for years. They check file signatures and monitor downloads. Windows comes with security software. Anti-virus programs are powerful but often breed a sense of over confidence. Attackers and anti-virus companies are in a constant state of battle. Attackers get more resourceful and constantly introduce new viruses. There is a delay between first time attack is seen “in the wild” and a fix. This creates a window of vulnerability between virus release and antidote.
When traveling do not plug your USB devices into public charging ports, use your own AC adapter. Beside power USB supports data transfers so a malicious charger is able to infect your system. The same caution applies to USB flash drives, it you don’t know the source of the drive do not plug it into your system.
Phishing email looks like it originated from a legitimate company. The email typically states recipient needs to “log in” to a secure web site and review and update account information. The site looks real but is actually controlled by the attacker. Goal of Phishing attack is to obtain user account data so attacker is able to masquerade as the user. Phishing is a classic Man-in-the-Middle attack. I hate to admit it but I fell for a PayPal Phishing attack years ago. I quickly realized my mistake and went to the real site and changed account credentials. Hover over the link in the email to see the URL looks authentic for the site. Be sure to start all the way from the top level domain. One Phishing trick is to create a very long URL that looks OK if you only examine the first few subdomains. As a safeguard never login to an account from an email link, go directly to the site in question.
One of the most insidious forms of attack is using compromised computers to attack/spam other computers. Once an attacker is able to install executable code on a machine they not only have gained control of that computer but also potentially able to use that computer to attack others at will. What makes Zombie attacks devastating is often computer owner is not even aware PC is compromised. Often the first hint of a problem is a nasty email/letter from their ISP.
The biggest problem with cookies it when sites use then to correlate user activity across multiple web locations.
Companies are finding ever more obnoxious ways to extract information from customers. Spyware collects application usage information and forward it back to the company. It is also used to update targeted advertising. Spyware updates the ads and in some cases selectively displays advertising based on usage.
Zombies are often used in DoS (denial of service attack). A DoS attack floods the victim with bogus queries. To make attack more powerful many computers are used simultaneously in a Distributed Denial of Service attack. The attack does not corrupt or deface the victim but by overloading victim’s network or computers is able to takes service office line or degrade response time during the attack. DDoS attacks are common against popular sites and DNS servers.
Radio communication is easy to eavesdrop. An attacker can locate a distance away without having to compromise physical site security. An attacker can cause a Denial of Service DoS) attack and if account names and password are sent in the clear they can be harvested. During development of IEEE 802.11 Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN) this threat was recognized and provisions made for authentication and encryption called Wireless Equivalent Privacy (WEP). Unfortunately security researchers quickly discovered serious shortcomings in WEP. Weakness managing encryption key makes it relatively easy to determine the key thus breaking encryption. This prompted development of a stronger encryption scheme Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA2) using AES encryption. There are options optimized for home networks using a preshared key and for large organization using RADIUS authentication. There is a newer version called WPA3 but it is not yet commonly deployed.
Security Tip –POP/SMTP email send user credential in the clear. This is not a huge concern on wired or security protected Wi-Fi networks. It is a serious risk when using public hotspots as over the air is sent in the clear allowing anyone with a sniffer to grab your email passwords. If at all possible use SSL/TLS to log into email to protect username and password.
Powerline, Phoneline and Coax networks leak data beyond the confines of the network. An attacker can connect to phone, power or Cable some distance away and gain access to network traffic. This is especially critical in multifamily housing and office buildings where multiple tenants are in close proximity.
Wired Ethernet is less susceptible to eavesdropping because signaling is contained within wiring and LAN wiring does not typically exit the building.
Internet was designed to be robust in the face of equipment and communication failures. Unfortunately it is not designed to withstand deliberate willful attack to network components. Domain Name System (DNS) is the vehicle used to convert user-friendly names to computer friendly IP addresses. One of the ways to minimize unnecessary load on DNS server is to cache recently used information. DNS poisoning exploits a weakness in DNS to plant bogus cached information. Once cache is corrupted computers accessing that DNS server are directed to incorrect site controlled by the attacker. A high priority initiative is to implement Domain Name System Security Extensions (DNSSEC) to counteract this sort of attack and increase level of confidence in DNS.
Man in the middle is a cryptographic attack where an intruder intersperses himself between two parties. Once in position intruder is able to intercept traffic from each party and forward it to the other without either being aware of the attack. The attacker in turn is able to modify messages an observe passwords.
Until recently this sort of attack was rare because attacker needed to intercept traffic by being located within ISP or internet backbone. With widespread use of public Wi-Fi hot spots and even recently Cell sites this type of attack is becoming more common. Some ruse is used to cause user to connect to attacker’s site. Site is often an exact replica of a real site. Once user has been fooled into connecting to bogus site attacker is free to spoof site information and capture user’s authentication credentials.
Computers work by receiving information, creating copies – either temporary or permanent, modifying the information as needed to accomplish desired task, make more copies of modified data and often sending it to a third party. These records are a gold mine for legitimate businesses, law enforcement, and criminals. Digital data is easy and cheap to capture and transmit. Once captured this treasure trove of information often escapes control of those who have created it winding up in unsavory hands.
Limit the amount of personal information you divulge. You need to disclose just enough information to conduct the transaction. Often times you can use an alias such as in chat rooms and forums. Companies want to harvest your information to sell you stuff. It is surprising, and scary, how much information can be gathered about someone by simply following them to different sites.
The explosion of social media creates another avenue where personal information can be unwittingly released into the wild or harvested for nefarious purposes. Members offer unwittingly post sensitive personal information that winds up being widely distributed.
A less obvious vector for malware is web page ad insertion. Many web sites depend on advertising revenue to survive. Add insertion is contracted out to a third-party resulting in not only the annoyance of inane ads but also the possibility of advertising malware. To deal with this we have been using an ad blocker Adblock Plus.
For machines running Windows the Windows update tool is a convenient way to install the latest security patches. As with anti-virus software it is important to stay current. Once vulnerability is discovered information about it is rapidly disseminated over the net. Many software applications also offer automatic monitoring of new releases and prompt the user to upgrade. However I’ve have noticed a trend to incessant updates and there is always the risk an update will break backward compatibility.
To make configuration easier most programs and operating systems use default settings. Check these carefully to make sure they do not compromise system integrity.
The web makes it easy to download and install software. It is hard to tell if a particular program is safe. Using antiviral software is helpful but it is not an absolute guarantee. It is possible to get infected before the antiviral program is updated.
Windows make it easier to limit unauthorized software installation by providing a pop up dialog box asking to approve installation. Much Windows software is digitally signed verifying it came from the vender it claims to come from. Note: signing says nothing about quality of the software just verifies who released it.
A security side effect of NAT is by default it drops incoming connection requests. If a remote host attempts to connect to the public IP address NAT ignores request because it doesn’t know which computer on LAN to forward it to. Only if explicit port forwarding rules are created will NAT know how to handle request. This is what gives NAT its firewall like characteristics for inbound connections.
The first line of defense is to control data entering and leaving the LAN. Unless you are running a public server incoming security is easy, refuse all incoming connection requests. Our business web and mail server are hosted externally. This means ALL requests that originate outside the SOHO LAN can be refused
A firewall imposes policy rules on data entering and leaving the network. Software firewall running on workstation, such as Windows built in firewall is able to control access based on individual application. Many low cost Broadband routers include some form or firewall.
In some respects firewall security is overrated. A machine without active listening services is impossible to attack remotely. If the host is running one or more services the firewall needs to allow incoming connection to the server. In that case the firewall is no longer part of the security scheme since it must allow data to pass. The server must be hardened to thwart malicious attack. Firewalls are great for keeping unnecessary traffic off the LAN and providing a secondary line of defense against incorrectly configured machines – but firewalls are not the magic bullet many people think they are.
Having duplicate copies of important data is critical to recovering from data loss, either accidental or deliberate. With available of large low cost drives both internal and external backup has never been easier.
When reading about various threats it is easy to become overwhelmed. Assuming you are using either a NAT router or firewall the first thing you notice when examining security logs is a tremendous number of “bad” packets. Very little of this traffic is actually an attack. Most is the result of incomplete sessions and mistyped or misprogrammed addresses. Before sending off an irate e-mail to your ISP complaining about being attacked may want to take a gander at this tongue in cheek posting called: You pinged me you dog, internet Paranoia. Security is a balance, taking reasonable precautions go a long way to keeping oneself safe in the digital world.
Networks occasionally fail. Good troubleshooting skills are necessary to determine root cause. For a small SOHO network good use can be made of the diagnostic tools built into Windows and indicators on most Ethernet devices. Hardware, software, and service vendors can be a good diagnostic source. However consumer products are very competitively priced, that limits how much one-on-one support a vendor is willing to provide. There are many internet resources, besides the product vendor, able to help resolve end user issues. My favorite is DSLReports.
Windows includes a number of command line utilities to help debug network issues. To run the desired utility press the Windows key and the R key simultaneously type cmd, or use the Windows search feature and type cmd. This opens the command prompt, commonly called the DOS box.
There are many ways to troubleshoot problems. The most comprehensive is to start at the bottom and work your way up. This insures you do not miss anything but can be time consuming. Another option is to start in the middle, if that works you know the problem is after that level. When troubleshooting wireless problems a good first step is to see if the wired connection is working. No sense trying to fix a Wi-Fi problem if the network itself is not working properly.
Even with a small home network documentation is important and will save time later. No matter how obvious something seems now a couple of years down the road it can be a head scratcher. I created an Excel spreadsheet listing: device description, purchase date, MAC address and IP address if set statically. I used MS Word to document the patch panel and Ethernet switch port utilization. Did the same for 66-blocks used for telephone wiring.
The trick is to be disciplined enough to keep documentation up to date. It is fun going back through early revisions of the network to see how things have evolved over time.
Ethernet cards, hubs and switches typically include a number of indicators that are very helpful troubleshooting aids.
Active connection between card and hub/switch
Indicates link speed
Full Duplex/Half duplex
Half duplex when used with a hub and full duplex with switch
Flashes during transmission or reception
Flashes when hub detects collision
If Link indicator is off link is inactive. This is most likely a cable fault or Ethernet hardware failure.
Ethernet cards automatically select optimum speed. For 100 and 1,000 Mbps operation both sides must be capable of the same speed and wiring meet Cat5 or Cat 6 requirements. When connected to a hub Ethernet runs in half duplex (HDX). Ethernet switches allow simultaneous send and receive - Full Duplex (FDX). When using a hub collision frequency gets worse as utilization increases. Occasional collisions are nothing to worry about. Hubs have been obsolete for many years so rarely seen on a residential network.
In Windows go to the Network Connections page and click on the interface you are using. Either use the GUI or type NCPA.CPL. All network interfaces will be displayed. Hover over the desired interface and right mouse click. If the word Status is not in bold the PC does not think that interface is connected to a network. If you prefer command line troubleshooting type the command: GETMAC –v. It will display each interface and whether or not Windows thinks it has an active connection.
If the desired device does not show up at all that means Windows does not think it exists. Sometimes an interface may lock up. Unplug the PC from power; do not just turn it off. This makes sure power is removed from everything except the RTC. Leave it off for a few seconds and try to reboot.
Debug tip – If cable is not terminated correctly end-to-end continuity may exist but pairs miswired, causing a condition known as a split-pair. A split pair cable will often operate at 10 Mbps but fail at higher speed.
The modem connects the customer to ISP network: FTTP, Cable, ADSL, satellite, or if you are very unlucky dialup. Modem stats provide a powerful diagnostic aid since it reports the condition of the physical interface rather than end-to-end performance.
The Status page of our ADSL2 router shows DSL link speed, errors and IP settings. If you can get to the modem the good news is at least your LAN is working correctly even if you cannot access the internet.
Figure 19 Modem/Router status
PING is a Windows command line utility to determine if a remote machine is reachable. The host is specified by either IP address or domain name. PING uses internet Control Message Protocol (ICMP) to determine round trip time to the remote host. Not all hosts respond to Ping, some administrators disable it. It is a good ideal prior to troubleshooting to have a host in mind. I like using DSLReports because I use the site a lot and it responds to Ping.
In the first example we ping a local PC its IP address. In the second case we ping a public web server on the internet by its domain name. When pinging by name the first step is to translate host name to IP address. If you are able to Ping an internet host by IP address but not by URP there is a problem with the DNS resolver. Try configuring one of the PCs with public DNS resolver. I use Google’s 220.127.116.11 just because it is easy to remember. This quickly determines if DNS is working correctly. The third example shows a typical report when the host ignores ping requests.
Tip – Ping is extremely useful but not all routers and hosts respond. If a device does not respond need to determine if that is because of a problem or it is configured to ignore Ping.
Example 1: Ping local computer IP address.
Pinging 192.168.2.2 with 32 bytes of data:
Reply from 192.168.2.2: bytes=32 time=2ms TTL=128
Reply from 192.168.2.2: bytes=32 time=1ms TTL=128
Reply from 192.168.2.2: bytes=32 time=1ms TTL=128
Reply from 192.168.2.2: bytes=32 time=1ms TTL=128
Example 2: Ping remote host by DNS Name.
Pinging DSLreports.com [18.104.22.168] with 32 bytes of data:
Reply from 22.214.171.124: bytes=32 time=63ms TTL=47
Reply from 126.96.36.199: bytes=32 time=62ms TTL=47
Reply from 188.8.131.52: bytes=32 time=62ms TTL=47
Reply from 184.108.40.206: bytes=32 time=62ms TTL=47
Example 2: Ping remote host by DNS Name, ICMP response disabled.
Pinging www.cnn.com [220.127.116.11] with 32 bytes of data:
Request timed out.
Request timed out.
Request timed out.
Request timed out.
Trace route (Tracert in Windows) determines round trip time to each hop between user and remote host. This information is useful to determine underlying cause of slow internet response or unavailable hosts. Trace route uses Time to Live (TTL) parameter to control at which hop the packet expires. When a router receives a packet with an expired TTL it discards the packet and informs sender TTL expired. Trace route uses this information to build a path map and response time list to each hop between source and destination.
Round trip time increases with distance and hop count. A sudden unexplained increase typically means that hop or previous one is congested. PING is given a low priority so it is not uncommon for a router or server to ignore it. In that case Trace route responds with an “*” indicating nothing was returned.
Windows includes a command line Trace route utility, TRACERT. VisualRoute provides a graphical format.
Typical TRACERT report:
Tracing route to dslreports.com [18.104.22.168] over a maximum of 30 hops:
1 <1 ms <1 ms <1 ms 192.168.2.1
2 34 ms 33 ms 33 ms xx.milford1-1.nh.g4.net [22.214.171.124]
3 35 ms 35 ms 35 ms 126.96.36.199
4 35 ms 34 ms 34 ms manchester0-8.nh.G4.net [188.8.131.52]
5 37 ms 37 ms 36 ms 216-107-229-217.static.firstlight.net [184.108.40.206]
6 37 ms 37 ms 37 ms 66-109-52-101.tvc-ip.com [220.127.116.11]
7 39 ms 39 ms 39 ms be13.albnypscr1.ip.firstlight.net [18.104.22.168]
8 40 ms 40 ms 39 ms be23.albynypsbr1.ip.firstlight.net [22.214.171.124]
9 65 ms 64 ms 65 ms equinix-chi.liquidweb.com [126.96.36.199]
10 72 ms 71 ms 71 ms lw-dc3-core1.rtr.liquidweb.com [188.8.131.52]
11 71 ms 71 ms 70 ms lw-dc3-storm1.rtr.liquidweb.com [184.108.40.206]
12 71 ms 71 ms 71 ms www.dslreports.com [220.127.116.11]
AngryIP is a useful utility to view information about which devices are connected to the LAN. Also facilitates finding unauthorized devices. In our case the lower addresses are dynamic and those above 100 statically assigned to servers.
Figure 19 Angry IP LAN Scanner
Belarc Advisor is a freeware (for personal use) application that displays Windows hardware and software configuration information and whether or not security patches are up to date.
inSSIDER is a handy troubleshooting tool for wireless problems. It scans all 2.4 and 5 GHz channels (assuming radio supports both) and display signal level, network name and encryption type. If you are in an urban area it is truly amazing how many wireless networks there are. Even though there is often more than one network on a given channel Wi-Fi radios are able to cut through the clutter and deliver fast internet access. This utility used to be shareware now it is paid, may be able to find old shareware version still available.
On my Android phone I use Wi-Fi Analyzer by Vrem.
Ipconfig is a Windows command line utility that displays IP settings for each network interface. If Point-to-Point Protocol (PPP) or VPN is used they are also shown. With the advent of IPv6 the IPCONFIG /ALL command gets pretty verbose with all the tunnel adapters. Tunnel adapters are software that allows data to move between IPv4 and IPv6 networks.
Adapter address is the hardware address assigned to the physical network interface. For Ethernet this is a 48-bit Media Access Controller (MAC) address. Dialup PPP assigns a dummy MAC to the adapter. Default Gateway is the address packets are sent to connect to foreign hosts. DHCP server is the address of the dynamic host controller protocol server. At power up client emits a DHCP discovery message to find active DHCP servers. DNS server is the address of the name server. In a simple network DNS, Gateway and DHCP address will typically be that of the broadband router.
Windows IP Configuration
Host Name . . . . . . . . . . . . : TomZ230
Primary Dns Suffix . . . . . . . :
Node Type . . . . . . . . . . . . : Hybrid
IP Routing Enabled. . . . . . . . : No
WINS Proxy Enabled. . . . . . . . : No
Ethernet adapter Ethernet:
Connection-specific DNS Suffix . :
Description . . . . . . . . . . . : Intel(R) Ethernet Connection I217-LM
Physical Address. . . . . . . . . : C4-34-6B-51-6F-D0
DHCP Enabled. . . . . . . . . . . : Yes
Autoconfiguration Enabled . . . . : Yes
IPv4 Address. . . . . . . . . . . : 192.168.2.6(Preferred)
Subnet Mask . . . . . . . . . . . : 255.255.255.0
Lease Obtained. . . . . . . . . . : Friday, December 6, 2019 7:20:38 AM
Lease Expires . . . . . . . . . . : Monday, December 9, 2019 2:02:01 PM
Default Gateway . . . . . . . . . : 192.168.2.1
DHCP Server . . . . . . . . . . . : 192.168.2.1
DNS Servers . . . . . . . . . . . : 192.168.2.1
NetBIOS over Tcpip. . . . . . . . : Enabled
Netsh is a Windows command line scripting utility to modify network setting useful for resetting TCP/IP stack.
In Vista and later operating systems it is a handy way to troubleshoot wireless issues. Typing the command: “netsh wlan show interfaces” displays the wireless network name (SSID), the MAC address of the access point as well as the MAC address of the computer.
Netstat is another handy command line utility. The –a option displays connections and listening ports. Using the -e option displays Ethernet stats including errors.
Bytes 1755562572 217462740
Unicast packets 2768763 1839936
Non-unicast packets 86562 85233
Discards 0 0
Errors 0 0
Unknown protocols 0
Network discovery is used in small LAN to allow computers to see each other and access shares.
LANscan is a utility that displays the name of each computer (assuming it supports NetBIOS) on the LAN and which one is the Master Browser. The Master Browser works with SMBv1. Microsoft has depreciated SMBv1 in Windows 10 due to security issues. Win 10 now uses WS-Discovery. This should be turned on automatically when enabling file sharing. Below is a typical LANscan output in a Windows 10 network. Note none of the computers are flagged as MASTER because SNBv1 is not enabled.
LANscanner v2.02 - ScottiesTech.Info
-- 192.168.2.109 00-22-12-02-01-b0
-- 192.168.2.5 1c-56-fe-aa-51-34
-- 192.168.2.108 c0-ff-d4-ce-11-c7
-- 192.168.2.101 34-64-a9-61-25-2d
-- 192.168.2.107 00-22-12-02-08-19
-- 192.168.2.106 00-22-12-02-04-32
-- 192.168.2.105 00-22-12-02-04-af
-- 192.168.2.104 00-22-12-02-0d-3b
NETGEAR30FB4C 192.168.2.102 20-4e-7f-30-fb-4c WORKGROUP
TOM-T520 192.168.2.3 74-e5-0b-d5-90-c0 HOMELAN
TOMZ230 192.168.2.6 C4-34-6B-51-6F-D0 HOMELAN
TRIBBLE2 192.168.2.10 00-21-cc-67-06-80 HOMELAN
The Acronis system backup tool also comes in handy for managing hard disk partitions and cloning new drives in order to upgrade a system. If you just need to clone a drive, say to install and SSD I’ve used Macrium Reflect
DNS servers operate behind the scene largely unnoticed until something goes wrong. Normally an ISP provides the address of two DNS server so if the primary goes down the backup is able to resolve queries. When that occur will likely notice browsing problem that looks like slow internet access. Most web pages consist of many parts each with a unique URL. If the primary DNS server fails system waits for a response when it times out it tries the backup server. This is manifest as very slow browsing.
Gibson Research has a handy DNS benchmarking tool to evaluate DNS performance.
If your ISP is having trouble with their DNS Windows networking has a nifty feature that even though the computer is set for dynamic IP addressing you are able to set DNS statically. To do this go to properties on the desired network interface and select IPv4 properties. The lower portion of the dialog box has entries for DNS. I typically use the Google public DNS server address of 18.104.22.168 because it is easy to remember. Wikipedia has a short list of public DNS servers or do an internet search for public DNS.
When you need to get down and dirty to see exactly what is going on over the wire nothing beats a packet sniffer. Sniffers observe and display incoming and outgoing packets. If you have a network with managed switches switch can be configured to pass packets of interest to the test PC. When used with unmanaged switch need to run Wireshark on the PC of interest. This is one of the downsides of using switches vs hubs since switches limit most traffic to selected endpoints. Ethereal is a very popular open source diagnostic program recently renamed Wireshark.
If you are having problem reaching a specific web site I find Uptrends useful. It tests access from multiple locations worldwide. This lets you know if the problem is the website itself or just your connection.
Speed testing measures end-to-end file transfer speed. For most SOHO networks ISP first-mile link will be the principal determinate of speed. However it is possible congestion elsewhere in network is degrading performance. There are numerous speed test utilities. The two I use the most often are DSL Reports and Speedtest.net.
If you need to test file transfer performance between PCs on your LAN use IPERF
The key to effective debugging is to break complex systems into bite size chunks and build on what you know works. One of the nice things about using a router is it provides a clear demarcation point between LAN and internet. First step is determining if the problem is the LAN or internet. I typically use the most likely and easiest technique first. Do the easy stuff first even it is not the most likely. If that does not resolve the problem work your way through the list in a methodical fashion.
Many improvements in wiring technology were developed by the Telephone industry to deal with massive number of circuits they install and manage. Of particular significance for our purposes are modular jacks and type 66 and 110 punch down blocks.
Modular jacks were developed by the old US Bell Telephone System to reduce cost of installing and maintaining customer equipment. Until the 1970s phones were hardwired. This required a craftsperson to come on site for even the simplest task. Deployment of modular jacks meant that in many instances customers could: repair, move, or install their own equipment. Within the old Bell system they were known as registered jacks. A uniform service ordering code (USOC) defined the physical jack, type of mounting, and how the jack was connected to the telephone network.
About the same time as modular jacks became popular Type 66 punch down termination was introduced. It is called punch down because each conductor is terminated with a spring-loaded tool that pushes a wire into an insulation displacement contact and automatically cuts it to length. 66 style blocks are still widely used for phone systems. LAN wiring uses second-generation termination Type 110. 110 terminals are smaller allowing more circuits to be terminated in a given area. Due to its smaller size 110 provides better high frequency performance than type 66. There are other types of insulation displacement technology but these two are the most relevant for our purposes.
Prior to Telecommunication Industry Association EIA/TIA 568D Commercial Building Telecommunications Cabling Standard and EIA/TIA 570 Residential Telecommunication Cabling Standard wiring requirements were developed by various industry groups or in many cases equipment vendors themselves. TIA recognized cable infrastructure has a long life expectancy. It is typically used with multiple generations of electronic equipment. TIA devised a performance based wiring scheme independent of usage and equipment. This was a breakthrough; almost all communication systems now use structured wiring. TIA Structured wiring implements a home-run wiring method between a centralized wiring closet and terminal devices. Horizontal wiring originates at a patch panel in an equipment room and runs to jacks near the network device. Short patch cables connect devices to jacks and patch panel jacks to network infrastructure equipment.
When US telephone network was deregulated the FCC took on responsibility for end user equipment and inside wiring standards, called Customer Premise Equipment (CPE). Phone company practice for the previous 100 years was to wire phone jacks as a daisy chain. Outside wiring, called customer drop, terminated at a lightning protector. Inside wire originated at the protector and ran to the first outlet, from there to the next, and so on. As customers began using more sophisticated services limitation of this method became apparent. FCC mandated telephone inside wiring confirm to TIA structured wiring guidelines. Adoption of TIA structured wiring means identical wiring methods are used for both voice and data.
Today much internet LAN traffic is carried wirelessly using Wi-Fi. However even though the connection to the end device is wireless the Access Point most often needs an Ethernet link back to the LAN.
When the old Bell system moved to connectorized customer premise equipment (CPE) it created a family of modular connectors. Modular connectors come in 4, 6 and 8 position versions. A center locking key prevents the plug from being accidentally ejected from the receptacle.
As US telephone industry was migrating to modular connectors it was also in early stage of divesture and FCC mandated CPE interconnect. For the first time Customers Premise Equipment (CPE) could directly connect to the telephone network. This resulted of many tariff offerings defining various interconnect arrangements. Each tariff not only defined the type of jack, but whether it was flush or surface mount and how it connected to the telephone network. The system was called Uniform Service Ordering Code (USOC) Registered Jack (RJ) designation. Today most Registered Jack designations are only of historical interest. The RJ nomenclature has passed into popular usage only loosely coupled to its original intent. The more precise way to refer to modular jacks is in term of positions and contacts. For example the single line phone jack commonly referred to as RJ11 is a 6P2C; it is a 6-position modular connector of which only 2 contacts are used. The two line version the RJ14 is a 6P4C. The connector used for Ethernet referred as the RJ45 is more properly called an 8P8C.
The 4-position connector is used to connect telephone handset to phone. It is not assigned a RJ designation as it was never intended as an interface point for customer equipment.
The most popular 6-position jack is referred to as RJ11. It connects single line voice grade telephone equipment to the public switched telephone network (PSTN). A two-line version using the 6-position jack is the RJ14. Analog phones are often called POTS for Plain Old Telephone Service.
8-position RJ31 and RJ38 jacks connect alarm systems to the PSTN.
The 8-position RJ48C and RJ48X jacks are used for Business Class T-1 carrier.
TIA choose 8P8C jack for structured wiring. This jack is often erroneously called RJ45. USOC RJ45 connects analog data equipment to the PSTN. A resistor in the Jack is used to set transmit power level.
RJ11 6-position jack connects a single-line phone to the telephone network using pins 3 and 4. RJ14, also 6-position, is used with two-line phone using pins 3 and 4 for line 1, and pins 2 and 5 for line 2. An infrequently used three line version RJ25 uses pins 1 and 6 for the third line.
RJ31 and RJ38 are 8-position jacks used with alarm dialers. The jack is placed in series with the phone line close to the Telephone Company Network Interface Device (NID). Phones are wired downstream of the jack. Shorting bars within the jack establish continuity when the alarm is not plugged in. Inserting the alarm plug opens the circuit placing the alarm in series with CPE devices. This allows the alarm dialer to disconnect downstream CPE devices so it is able to seize line and dial out even if line was being used. RJ38 is identical to RJ31 except it has a strap between positions 2 and 7. This allows dialer to determine if it is plugged into a jack.
Uncommon in residential use RJ48C and RJ48X are 8-position jacks used to terminate 1.544 Mbps T-1 digital service. Receive pair use pins 1-2 transmit 4-5. RJ48X provides automatic Loopback when plug is removed. Unlike other 8-position USOC jacks pairing arrangement is compatible with TIA 568 so LAN patch cables can be used.
The first type of insulation displacement terminal was the 66 block. These continue to be used extensively. 66-block terminates 25 cable pairs. The four terminals are bussed together allowing multiple terminations. An advantage of the 66 family is it accepts larger gauge wire than newer 110. Type 66 blocks are typically attached to a standoff bracket screwed to the wall or backer board. The bracket allows building wiring to be run underneath the block making for a neat installation.
Building wiring is terminated on one set of 66 blocks and equipment on another. Interconnect is accomplished with cross connect wire. This allows a great deal of flexibility in adding and changing equipment over time. To save space split blocks can be used. In a split block each row of four terminals is divided in half. If needed, a bridging clip can be used to connect the terminal on left to the right side. Use of bridging clips facilitates troubleshooting allowing circuits to be easily isolated.
Type 110 terminals allow higher density wiring than Type 66. Typical 110 modules include a standoff. Building wiring is routed under the bracket through the standoff and fanned out to the appropriate location. Multiple position 110 blocks are then inserted over the base. 4-pair block are used for LANs and 5-pair for telephone wiring. Cross-connect wire is then punched down to the upper terminals of the block. Cross-connect blocks are mainly used with telephone wiring.
The 110 style terminal is also used on Structured wiring jacks allowing the same punchdown tool to be used for both.
The key to EIA/TIA 568 & 570 is the use of structured point-to-point wiring. A cable from each receptacle runs directly to a central wiring closet. Cable cannot be spliced or connected to other outlets. At the wiring closet each cable is terminated at a patch panel. To provide service a short cable, called a patch cable, is connected between patch panel and equipment used to service the room receptacle. At the other end another patch cable connects the receptacle to network device.
Structured wiring specification defines multiple wiring types: unshielded twisted pair (UTP) shielded twisted pair (STP) and fiber optic (FO). UTP is the overwhelming choice for home and commercial local area network (LAN) and telephone.
UTP cable is rated by Category; higher numeric designation indicates higher performance. TIA created Category 3, 4, 5, 5e 6, 6a. UTP structured cabling is designed for a maximum end-to-end distance of 100 meters (328 ft.). This distance includes a patch cord from device to wall jack, 90 meters of building wiring (in TIA parlance called horizontal wiring), and another patch cord in the wiring closet to connect facility cabling to network electronics.
Receptacles use type 110 punchdown terminations. This allows rapid termination with a punch down tool. In the wiring closet each cable is terminated at a jack on a patch panel. Using a patch panel allows short jumpers called a patch cable to connect individual drop to network gear. Patch panels are designed to mount on equipment racks. It is also possible to mount then directly on a will using a hinged bracket. Panel projects several inches from the wall in normal use but by unscrewing one side of the panel it swings out providing access to rear terminations.
Figure 25 Patch Panel
In office environments patch panels and active electronics are usually mounted on 19” racks. For residential use special wiring cabinets are often used to terminate phone, TV and LAN wiring and provide power for network devices.
The downside of residential wiring cabinets is space and power dissipation. My preference is to mount patch panel, punch down blocks and active equipment to a plywood backboard. This provides maximum flexibility.
Cat 5e supports Ethernet up to Gigabit (1000 Mbps) over a distance of 100 meters (328 feet), as well as ordinary phone service. Cat 3 can be used for phone service but cost is comparable to Cat 5e which provides greater flexibility. Cat 4 is obsolete. When Gigabit Ethernet was developed it was intended to use the installed base of Cat 5. However, real world experience showed that not all installations were up to the task, hence the minor revision Cat 5e (enhanced) to guarantee worst case compliance with Gig Ethernet. In reality well installed Cat 5 installation will probably work just fine with Gig Ethernet, especially the relatively short runs and low cable density typical of the home. Much of our early LAN wiring was done with Cat5 and it runs Gig Ethernet without error.
Cat 6 doubles bandwidth from 100 MHz for Cat 5e to 250 MHz IEEE recently released specification for 10G over UTP. As happened with Gig Ethernet during spec development it was found necessary to tweak the cabling spec. Due to the higher frequencies used in 10 G crosstalk from other nearby cables, called alien crosstalk, is a problem. Cat 6a (augmented) addresses this. Cat 6a cable has a larger outside diameter then Cat 6 to reduce alien crosstalk. If Cat6 rather than Cat6A is used maximum 10G distance is reduced from 100 to 55M, still more than adequate for most residential use.
Category 8 is pushing the limits of copper and is primarily intended for relatively short runs in data centers.
EIA/TIA is a US standards organization. Europe and rest of the world use similar standard defined by ISO/IEC 11801. Performance is grouped by Class rather than category. Class C is equivalent to Cat 3, Class D to Cat 5, and Class E to Cat 6.
Category rating is end to end. In order to meet the spec: wire, connectors, and installation practice must meet the appropriate grade. The various UTP category grades are outwardly similar. The differences are in the number of twists per inch and mechanical tolerances. The higher the Category rating the more tightly pairs are twisted and mechanical specifications are held to tighter tolerances. It is important not to mix components of different Category grades, doing so reduces overall rating to the lowest grade used.
The most common type of Category rated cable is UTP PVC. It can be used in most habitable spaces. The larger diameter of Cat 6a used with 10G Ethernet is increasing interest in screened cable. Screened cable has an outer foil shield. Screened cable is more difficult to work with but its smaller diameter is attractive when used with high density wiring such as data centers.
Where cable is installed in air handling space such as under a raised floor or within a suspended ceiling it must be Plenum rated. Plenum cable is insulated with Teflon rather than PVC. It is a common misperception Plenum rated cable is fire proof, which is not correct. Teflon is fire resistant not fire proof. The goal of Plenum cable is to delay onset of combustion until the fire is so advanced to make the space incompatible with life.
Outdoor wiring is subject to UV radiation and moisture degradation. Outdoor cable is typically gel filled (icky-pick) to prevent moisture intrusion and has a UV resistant outer jacket, usually black. Direct burial cable includes a corrugated metal rodent shield to protect against burrowing animals.
For long runs especially between buildings fiber is ideal. Being nonmetallic it is not susceptible to lightning damage. The downside of fiber is termination cost and cost of electro/optical converters.
Patch cables connect equipment to wall jack, and patch panel to network electronics. T568A and T568B pin out options can be ignored in patch cable since both ends are terminated by the manufacture.
Patch cables come in two versions, straight through and crossover. Straight through are used in most circumstances. UTP Ethernet uses a point-to-point wiring scheme. The transmit port of the computer connects to the receive port of the hub/switch and vice versa. If this arrangement cannot be used, for example two computers in direct connection or connecting a switch to another switch a crossover cable is used. Crossover cables are used with 10 and 100Mbps Ethernet to transpose transmit and receive pair at one end so like devices can be interconnected. The function of Crossover cable is identical to using an Uplink port on an Ethernet Hub or Switch.
Crossover cables are pretty much obsolete. Newer network devices implement Auto-MDIX that automatically determines transmitter and receiver. Gig and higher speed Ethernet use all four pair in a hybrid arrangement. Auto sensing eliminates need for crossover cables and uplink ports.
Figure 28 Patch Cable
A cause of much confusion when implementing EIA/TIA 568 structured wiring is the fact two different connector pin outs are defined: T568A and T568B. They are nearly identical except pairs 2 and 3 are swapped. Electrically this is of no consequence as long as both ends use the same pin out.
The connector pinout version should not be confused with the revision level of the 568 specification itself. The latest version of the TIA 568 specification is D.
Figure 29 8P8C Structured Wiring Jacks
Pairing arrangement of TIA differs from that used on USOC voice jacks. The Inner two pairs are the same but outer two differ. This was done to improve high frequency transmission characteristics.
The inner two-pair of TIA-568 8-postion jack mates with inner two pair of RJ11 and RJ14 USOC 6-position plug. This eliminates need for adapters when connecting RJ11 and RJ14 equipment to 8-pos structured wiring. EIA/TIA 568 commercial and EIA/TIA 570 residential structured wiring specifications require use of T568A pinnout unless building is already wired with B. T568A is preferred because inner two pair map directly to pair 1 and 2 on USOC punch down blocks, making cross connection easier. T568B is popular in the United States because it uses the same pin out as AT&T Merlin key systems in widespread use when the structured wiring standard was being developed.
Legacy Telco USOC RJ11 and RJ14 jacks use green, red, black and yellow conductors. TIA Category rated cable consist of 8-conductors, arraigned as 4-twisted pairs. Each pair is a different color, to identify conductors within each pair one wire is solid color (Ring) the other has a White stripe (Tip). The term Tip and Ring refer to old style manual switch boards where operator had to physically insert a phone jack to make the connection.
Standard Telephone practice has Tip conductor positive with respect to Ring. Early touchtone phones were polarity sensitive. Today most telephone equipment includes a diode bridge so polarity is unimportant. However it is good practice to maintain proper polarity. Low cost phone line testers are available to quickly determine polarity.
TIA Color Code
Telco Color Code
Pair 1 pin 5
Pair 1 pin 5
Tip + Line 1
Pair 1 pin 4
Pair 1 pin 4
Pair 1 pin 4
Pair 1 pin 3
Pair 2 pin 3
Pair 2 pin 1
Tip + Line 2
Pair 2 pin 2
Pair 2 pin 6
Pair 2 pin 2
Pair 2 pin 5
Pair 3 pin 1
Pair 3 pin 3
Pair 3 pin 2
Pair 3 pin 6
Pair 4 pin 7
Pair 4 pin 7
Pair 4 pin 8
Pair 4 pin 8
Traditional wired telephones are often called POTS (plain old telephone service). We have two wired phone lines, one for personal use and one for business. Lines are configured as a hunt group, also called transfer on busy. If line 1 is busy incoming calls are redirected to line 2. Hunting is unidirectional; if someone calls the second line and it is busy switch will not ring the first line. Residential telephone service reps may not be familiar with Hunting because it is a "business feature." You may have to press the rep a little to get it. Surprisingly there was no extra charge for this feature, probably because it results in more completed calls.
Before the advent of broadband internet we made extensive use of dialup. Dialup uses the public telephone network to provide internet access. Unlike ADSL a dialup connection actually places a phone call to the ISP and ties up the line for the duration of the session. If someone picks up a phone it will disconnect the session and if the phone is in use when the modem attempts to initiate the call it will interfere with the voice call. For readers still stuck on dialup I designed a device to minimize interference between dialup and phone lines. More information about the Modem Access Adapter (MAA) is available on the writings page.
For some years after we were able to get ADSL I maintained dialup as a backup. We no longer do so. DSL service has been very reliable. With web sites increasing being optimized for broadband dialup browsing is painfully slow.
In the bad old days before US telecom divestiture early 1980’s. The Phone Company delivered phone service, wired customer’s premise and leased all telephone equipment. With divestiture Phone Company’s regulated responsibility was limited to delivering service to customer’s premise. Inside wiring and equipment became the customer’s responsibility. This created a dilemma for the Phone Company, how to determine if a problem was their responsibility or the customer?
Enter the NID (network interface device). NID is the demarcation point, between Phone Company and customer. It incorporates lightning protection and a method to easily disconnect customer premise equipment (CPE) from the telephone network. Over time NIDs evolved into a single integrated package.
The specific embodiment of the Network Interface Device (NID) has changed over the years but purpose remains the same: Terminate outside wiring; provide surge protection and disconnect inside wiring for testing. Some NIDs include a half-ringer test circuit. The half-ringer creates a unique signature to allow test equipment to determine if fault is on Telco or customer side. Modern NIDs use gas tube protectors rather than old style carbon block. Gas tube provides tighter control of overvoltage and being hermetically sealed minimizes added noise.
Picture above shows a typical multiline NID installed indoors, as opposed to more common location outside. Telephone Company wiring terminates under the protective cover on the left. The Telco side contains protection circuits that divert lightning surges to earth ground. The right hand side has provisions to connect CPE wiring and a test jack for each line. Opening the line module cover exposes a RJ11 test jack. Plugging a phone into the test jack automatically disconnects inside wiring. If phone works when plugged into the test jack problem is due to customer wiring or equipment, if not problem is with Telco.
ADSL shares the same phone line used to deliver POTS. Filters are required to prevent high frequency DSL signaling from interfering with voice. To reduce cost ISPs often send customer a self-install kit. The kit includes in-line filters that must be used by each non-DSL device connected to phone line.
Rather than using a micro filter at each non-DSL device I installed a POTS/DSL splitter. Splitter provides a low pass filter isolating voice from high frequency DSL. Splitter has two outputs; “Data” connected directly to the DSL modem and “Voice” connected to inside phone wiring. The splitter contains a half-ringer test circuit after the low pass POTS filter allowing the one in the NID to be removed. ADSL was designed to operate in the presence of half-ringer but it represents a small additional load.
In some cases the local phone company will install a splitter directly in the NID eliminating the need for customer installed external splitter or in-line filters.
Home Alarm Tip – If a phone is connected to splitter “Data” port it will work normally. This creates a potential safety hazard with a home alarm system. If a phone is inadvertently connected to the data port and it is in use when alarm needs to seize phone line it will be unable to do so. Care should be taken when using a splitter so only DSL modem is connected to “data” jack. The other option is to install splitter after alarm jack and filter alarm separately.
Historically 75 ohm coaxial was limited to RF TV distribution of: Over the air, Cable and Satellite. It is possible to use this cable to also carry digital data. A number of fiber ISPs are using MoCA technology to eliminate the need to run Category rated cable to set top boxes. If you need to provide wired internet and have coax cabling at the location this may be an option. As with UTP cabling special tooling is needed to strip, prep and install F style connectors.
Electronic devices create a jumble of cables, both data and power. Low power devices tend to use external power supplies, called wall warts, which take up a fair amount of space. After struggling with the clutter of multiple power strips I decided to organize power distribution and install a power distribution panel.
Power Panel requirements
To minimize power consumption devices that do not have to be on continuously are controlled automatically by the workstation. Power bricks take up a lot of space, so the number of outlets is generous. Panel has four always on strips with six receptacles each and three strips controlled by workstation.
During the upgrade to Win 10 I replaced PS/2 power sensing with a USB connection. When the workstation is turned on 5 volts from the USB connection activates a SSR (solid state relay) powering up peripherals.
The key to minimizing lightning and transient voltage damage is bonding all services together with a low impedance path to each other and to Earth. All conductors entering the building must be bonded together. Bonding minimizes the voltage difference between conductors during transient events. IEEE has a nice white paper about lightning and surge protection. A good analogy is to think of your home as a bank vault. The goal is to prevent dangerous voltages from passing through the perimeter and to insure everything metallic is at the same potential.
Recent versions of the National Electrical Code (NEC) require the installation of an intersystem bonding bridge. This insures all conductors are connected to an equipotential point to minimize differences in potential during transient events. Transient protectors are used to clamp overvoltage of ungrounded conductors by connecting to this bonding point.
A whole house surge protector should be used to protect electrical system. Goal is to direct transient energy into low impedance ground and to provide low impedance bonding of all metallic conductors. We use a GE THQLSURGE protector. Installation is easy. Device plugs into breaker panel much like an ordinary two-pole breaker. A small neon light indicates the protector is working correctly.
Surge protectors do not absorb energy they divert it. If diversion path is not low impedance a substantial voltage difference is created. This is what kills electronic gear.
The gas tube surge suppressor in the NID does a good job shunting surges to ground. In addition the whole house POTS/DSL splitter we use includes a semiconductor secondary surge suppressor.
If you are running telephone wiring to out buildings it is good practice to use surge suppressors where cable exits and enters each building.
Cable and Satellite providers bond the coaxial cable sheath, where it enters residence, to the building ground system. This insures sheath is as at same potential as building Earth ground. As with Telephone it is advisable to add secondary coaxial protection to limit transient voltage on the inner conductor.
We have an Over the Air (OTA) TV and FM antennas. They are grounded and bonded to the building ground system. A coaxial surge protector is used on each cable where it enters the building.
Once perimeter protection is in place installing point-of-use surge protectors offer additional transient protection. Since damage is caused by differences in potential between conductors ideally all conductors should pass through the surge protector for maximum effectiveness.
I found a nice commercial surge protector on eBay designed to be used with high power printers.
The Ametex ESP XG-PCS-15D surge protector does all the things expected plus if voltage remains too high or too low it disconnects the load. The built in LCD screen cycles through: Under-volt count, over volt count, power outage count, surge count, current voltage.
There is a cable you can use to connect them to a PC for detailed logging but I could not find any used ones and the new cost is over $50 so I decided to take a pass.
Proper tooling is essential to install a reliable network. Jacket ripper uses a sharp blade to cut through outer jacked without deforming twisted pair or cutting through insulation. Punch down tool with interchangeable blades for 66 and 110 termination is needed for both LAN and telephone work. I found a handy palm rest at a local big box home center to hold the Jack during termination. This makes termination easier. I use a Rino hand labeler to mark cable ends. This is a handy little device that dispenses and cuts cable labels.
When I initially installed our LAN crimped modular jacks directly to building cable. Since then I have switched to using a patch panel and factory made patch cables. Still, being able to fabricate custom cables is occasionally useful. When attaching modular plugs be sure to get ones designed for the type of cable you are using: solid or stranded because the contacts are different.
Once cabling is installed commercial installations perform full parametric testing to verify system meets applicable performance standards. That test equipment is very expensive and not practical for the casual installer. There are numerous continuity testers in to $20-$50 range. These low cost tester are only able to verify continuity and shorts, will not detect excessive untwist, split-pair etc. Still for the price is a great time saver to verify cable is property terminated.
Phone line tester is handy for checking active telephone lines. It verifies line polarity, voltage, loop current and ringing voltage. If you do a lot of telephone work a buttset is handy to have. A buttset is a special purpose telephone designed for testing.
If you are faced with the task of identifying unknown cables a toner is invaluable. Toner consists of two parts a tone generator and sensor. The generator places a signal on the wire. When the sensor is brought near it emits a tone due to capacitive coupling.
Lastly I found cable breakout tester, typically called a banjo, to come in handy doing nonstandard wiring. It provides access to individual conductors to verify wiring.
Cut cable to length
Removes outer cable jacket
Punch down Tool
Terminate Punch down terminals
Terminate 110 blocks
Terminate 66 blocks
Holds Jacks being terminated
Crimps cable into modular plug
Snake wire through walls
Identifies Cable ends
Phone line Tester
Indicates polarity and loop current of phone circuit
Verifies proper installation of Category rated wiring
Portable telephone to test phone line
Electrical access to each wire
Figure 33 LAN & Telephone Tools
Telephone and LAN wiring terminates at different locations. Telephone NID, secondary lightning protection, POTS/DSL splitter, test jacks, test phone and Type 66 punch down blocks are located at the outer wall of the basement near where the services enter the building. LAN UTP cabling terminates in a utility closet in the center of the basement. This location houses the DSL modem/router, Ethernet switch and UPS.
Figure 34 SOHO Telephone Wiring
Telco NID is located in basement. A POTS/DSL splitter is connected to business line. Splitter “Data” port runs directly to DSL modem. “Voice” port terminates at 66-block to be connected to multiple phones.
To make changes easier all building wiring is terminated on 66 style punch down blocks. Cross-connect wire is a single twisted pair used to interconnect building wiring. This makes it easy to rearrange wiring by adding and removing cross-connects. Test jacks connected to each line allow a test phone to be conveniently plugged in during troubleshooting. The test jacks are different than the ones in the NID in that connecting a phone does not disconnect downstream wiring.
An old style Western Electric wall phone is permanently mounted in wiring closet, with a RJ11 corded plug. This allows test phone to be plugged into the CPE test jacks or directly into the NID. Having phone permanently located in wiring closet insures it is available when needed.
House was built in 1982 predating SOHO networking. LAN wiring closet is in center of basement rather than at outer edge with phone wiring to optimize cable runs. LAN wiring has been expanded over the years. When first installed wired a few drops in the basement. Several years later added drops in bedrooms. Recent additions have been to add several home automation controllers.
When I initially installed LAN did not use patch panel. Instead terminated each cable with a modular plug and plugged cable directly into a small Ethernet hub (home network predates widespread use of switches). Modular plugs are more difficult to install than receptacles so this is not for the faint of heart. Over time some of the drops failed due to connector problems. Rewired the system using a 24-port 1U rack mounted Patch Panel. Like most other networking items Patch Panels have gotten dramatically cheaper over the years. I used a 1U hinged bracket to mount panel to the wall. With the addition of multiple home automation controllers all 24 ports are terminated, even thou not all are currently being used.
The ISP supplied TP-Link TD-8817 DSL router lives in the same closet as the patch panel and Ethernet switch. One of the patch panel drops terminates in the Telephone wiring closet. The “data” port of the whole house POTS/DSL splitter is connected at that end and a RJ11 patch cable connects the patch panel port to the modem. An Ethernet patch cord connects the router LAN port to the Ethernet switch.
I wanted to locate the Ethernet switch directly above the patch panel but the switch is not rack mountable. I bent a piece of thin gauge aluminum stock to act as a shelf above patch panel. This provides a convenient place for the Ethernet switch. Switch connects to patch panel with 1-foot patch cables.
Switch is a Netgear Prosafe Plus GS116Ev2 16-port fanless Gig switch. The switch is an interesting hybrid between dumb unmanaged and full blown manage switch. It can simply be plugged in and it works as a dumb switch. A built in web server provides access to advanced features. So far I have been very happy with my decision to upgrade.
The IEEE 802.11n standard represents a significant advantage over previous b and g generations. I replaced our preN AP with a Netgear wn802tv2. This AP does not have provisions for a guest network, if I was purchasing a new AP today that is a required feature.
Setup was pretty straightforward. AP defaults to static IP address 192.168.0.233. To configure AP connected it to wired port on my laptop and configured the laptop statically to match the settings of the AP. Logged into the AP and changed AP network settings to match our LAN. I set network resources statically above the range used by DHCP
Debugged connection without security then configured WPA2 AES. We do not have a RADIUS authentication server so selected WPA2 pre-shared key mode. With a pre shared key each device must be configured with a passphrase. This eliminates need for RADIUS authentication. PSK requires the passphrase be entered into each device. This is labor intensive, on a large network but not a big deal for a small one. An important downside of PSK is if a device is lost or stolen the passphrase needs to be changed or the intruder will have easy access to your network.
Ideally passphrase should be random and very long to defeat dictionary lookup attack. Good passphrases are difficult to generate manually. Luckily the internet once again comes to the rescue with online passphrase generators.
WPA2 has several encryption options, for maxim security and performance use AES not TKIP. Temporal Key Integrity Protocol was developed as an intern improvement to address serious weaknesses discovered in the original encryption scheme Wireless Equivalent Privacy (WEP). TKIP is in essence a wrapper around the flawed WEP, as such is it more computationally intensive and not quite as secure as AES. Unless you need backward compatibility with old Wi-Fi clients use AES.
I built a DIY UPS to power the LAN in the event of utility failure. The UPS is plugged into a surge protector. The UPS powers the modem/router, Ethernet switch and Wi-Fi access point. The battery is sized for multiple hours of operation so we do not loose internet access when we are not running the backup generator. Rather than using an inverter to create AC only to have the wall warts convert it back to DC I power the LAN gear directly from the battery.
The DSL router and Ethernet switch are connected directly to the UPS. The AP is located in 2nd floor closet. I used a power inserter that “steals two pair of the 4-pair Cat rated cable to deliver power. This setup is not PoE complainant but it was a cheap want not to have to run power cabling. This limits the AP connection to 100 Mbps but as our internet service is only 7 Mbps that is not a problem. If needed I can always run dedicated power wiring to the AP.
I configured the servers and home automation devices with static IP addresses. The odd man out is the file server. I initially set it statically but due to Windows 10 problem had to set it dynamically and use the router’s MAC reservation feature to maintain a stable IP address.
The remaining devices are set for DHCP, including our children’s Wi-Fi gadgets. That way they are able to use our Wi-Fi when visiting rather than using expensive cell data.
All the non-portable devices use the NTP time service running on the server to obtain network time. The server in turn is pointed to pool time servers.
During any discussion about wiring the topic of future proofing is bound to come up. The problem is wiring and buildings have very long life expectancies. It is difficult to anticipate network requirement 10 – 50 years down the road. Some folks are proponents of the “kitchen sink” approach, wire up every possible location with every sort of physical connection that may be needed. The down side is excessive upfront cost and it is rather brittle in the face of changing needs and technology.
Try to anticipate near term needs but don’t go overboard. No matter how carefully you plan down the road you will find yourself in a situation where you need to add wiring for something completely unanticipated. My most recent Ethernet addition was adding a drop near our aquarium to support the PLC controller I designed. If you told me I needed an Ethernet drop by the aquarium when I first installed the LAN in 1998 I would have said you were crazy. To deal with the unanticipated try to include pathways that makes it easy to add wiring. Install empty conduits; build wiring chases etcetera to make modifications as easy as possible. I’ve been lucky. When we built the house there is ventilation duct used to blow air from the cathedral ceiling on the second floor down into the basement. That has turned out to be a lifesaving cable chase when I’ve needed to add wiring.
Every business should have at least a minimal internet presence. Creating a simple web site is neither difficult nor expensive. The web server can be located in-house or operated by a hosting service. Registering a domain name creates a permanent internet presence regardless of how the business connects to the internet or where the servers are located.
Even if you are not a business having your own domain is still advantageous. It gives you a personalized email address for as long as you want it. That makes it easy for folks to stay in touch. Having your own site gives you a great deal of freedom to use it as you please. This paper is a good example. I enjoy writing about what I am doing and the solutions to various problems I’ve worked out. My site provides a vehicle to post those articles. Lastly if you are in a technical field it can’t hurt your resume that you have your own site.
For most small to midsized businesses using a virtual server managed by a hosting service is the optimum strategy. Your server is located in a data center with virtually unlimited access to bandwidth. A single server is able to host many web sites resulting in very low cost. The server used for my site hosts several hundred other web sites.
The hosting service takes care of most of the technical details: setting up the various servers, registering a domain name and creating DNS records. This allows the customer to focus on the creative aspects of building a web site.
Creating the site itself requires a combination of artistic and technical skills. There are many software packages available to help create a web site. In some cases site development tools are provided by the hosting service as part of your contract. If you don’t want to develop the site yourself there are many companies that specialize in web site development.
The first decision is which Top-level domain (TLD) is most appropriate. The same name can be registered in multiple TLDs. This is commonly done when the company’s name is trademarked. Large companies often register variations on their name to prevent cyber squatters from registering confusing or derogatory domains. The COM and BIZ TLDs are for commercial use. Networking companies commonly use the NET TLD. Some TLDs are country specific such as .UK or .US. If you want to identify your company with a specific region they are a good choice. Many hosting services provide automated tools to register and setup a domain. Registrars coordinate with ICANN or other registration agencies to insure each domain name is unique within its respective TLD.
The registration process involves providing information on domain name ownership and creating records that point to the Nameservers used to tell remote users the IP address of your site. When you submit a proposed domain name the registrar database is examined to insure the request does not conflict with an existing name within the TLD. The new name is assigned provisionally in case another registrar has recently recorded the same name. After a little while the registration is made permanent or if name is already in use will need to choose a different name. If you really want a name that is already registered all is not lost. You can try to purchase it from the owner. When I registered my domain wanted schmidt.com but that was already registered by a printer in Minnesota so I picked tschmidt.com
With a registered domain name email is addressed to the domain, not a third party. This personalizes your businesses persona. Email is structured as username@yourdomain.TLD. Most hosting services allow multiple mailboxes. This enables employees or family members to have individual accounts without the need to run an internal mail server.
There are many ways to operate a public web server: hosting service virtual server, locate your equipment at a data center, or run the server locally.
Easiest way to set up a web site is with a hosting service. Use of a hosting service maintains 24/7/365 service and keeps site traffic off your internet connection. Virtual hosting is appropriate for low traffic sites. The hosting service runs multiple virtual web servers on a single physical server. We use a local hosting service Hollis Hosting at a cost of $40 per year plus another $15 for annual domain name registration. Most hosting services have business relationships with a domain registrar. This allows one stop shopping for domain registration/renewal and internet hosting. Our domain name is registered with eNom, a popular registrar used by many hosting services. The hosting service also runs virtual SMTP and POP servers to send and receive email.
Transferring your account from one hosting service to another is pretty easy. DNS registrar needs to be notified of new Nameservers and web site contents transferred from old to new server.
Normally one registers a domain name to create a public a server. Some hosting services allow customers to set up a web site without a domain name. The virtual site is assigned a name that looks something like http://www.hosting.net/~yourbiz. This uses the name of the service as the starting point of your site.
Most hosting services offer collocation where customers are able install their own equipment in a secure area. Collocation services typically provide redundant high-speed access and emergency backup power. This allows complete flexibility as to equipment and software used to support the site and restricts access to sensitive company data to in-house IT personnel.
Large companies often host their own sites since they have the necessary expertise and already run extensive data centers.
On site hosting is also an option for casual personal sites. To accomplish this one needs to set up a web server. Running the server on a dedicated PC is more secure than sharing the PC between web server and other functions because it is easier to constrain what the attacker is able to access if they compromise the computer. Abyss web server is free for personal use and runs on Windows PCs. I use it for our internal non-public web server.
Residential broadband is typically asymmetric; upload is much slower than download. This limits site performance. Heavy site traffic will interfere with other internet usage.
Most residential ISPs assign dynamic IP address assignment making it difficult to host a server as the address can change unpredictably. Dynamic DNS is a workaround. The DNS service is updated each time the server’s address changes. Software running on the customer side detects IP address changes and updates the dynamic DNS service. This works well for personal sites but be aware the site becomes temporarily inaccessible during the address update making it inappropriate for serious commercial use.
ISPs typically prohibit residential customers from operating servers. Some enforce this restriction aggressively other turn a blind eye unless there is a problem. Some ISPs block access to Port 80 used to access web sites forcing the use of a nonstandard port. This is not an issue if you are using the site it for personal access, simply append the port number to the URL so the web browser knows which port to use. For example: http://mysite.com:8080 Residential accounts are normally limited to a single IP address. This is a problem if more than one web server is needed. A workaround is to use a non-standard port, such as 8080, for one of the servers.
Information for each registered domain is located in the WHOIS databases maintained by RIR (regional internet registries. The database maintains administrative and technical contact information about the site. The Whois database does not maintain information about the site itself; it contains a list of authoritive nameservers. To find the IP address of a site one needs to query one of the nameservers associated with the site.
Administrative information records data about site ownership and contact.
Technical information records data about network operation center contact.
Nameservers’ listed in the Whois database are the authoritative servers for your domain. These are the servers used by DNS to convert a domain name to IP address. The registrar does not maintain information about the site itself, simply an address pointer to the Nameserver that does. Registrars require two Nameservers, primary and backup. Ideally DNS servers are in widely separate locations served by different providers. This minimizes risk the authoritive Nameserver ever becoming inaccessible.
Figure 35 WHOIS Domain Records
Once a domain is registered Nameserver records must be created. These records provide translation between URL and IP address. If you use a hosting service they will most likely setup the Nameserver for you. Still it is a good idea to understand basic concepts. A DNS record lookup utility is available to view DNS records. The site View DNS has a nice tool to check DNS entries for errors.
The name server maintains a number of different records. Below are commonly used record types.
Address records map host name to IP address.
Mail Exchange records provide the address of mail servers. The preference field allows more than one host to be used. This provides backup in case a mail server goes down.
Pointer Record translates host IP address to machine name. This performs reverse lookup based on address rather than name.
The Nameserver record provides the name of authoritive Nameservers for the domain. Authoritive servers are the primary repositories of domain information. Other servers called secondary name servers cache this information to speed up access. The information cached on secondary servers must be periodically refreshed.
The SOA denotes entry as the official source of information for the domain.
Serial number records revisions to the record. This allows other Nameservers to determine if the record has been revised and local copy needs to be updated. Preferred format for the serial number is YYYYMMDDNN. NN is an incrementing number that allows the record to be revised more than once per day.
Refresh indicate how often secondary servers should check authoritative server for changes.
Retry indicates how long secondary server should wait to reconnect if connection was refused.
Expire is how long secondary server should use the current entry if it is unable to contact the authoritive server.
Minimum indicates how long secondary servers should cache domain information.
Sender Policy Framework adds DNS record to allow mail servers to verify incoming email was sent from domain and not spoofed by spammer.
Figure 36 DNS Record
Creating a web site requires a combination of artistic and technical skills. Sites range from simple static web pages to complex database driven e-commerce sites able to perform credit card transactions. A word processor can be used to create a simple site. Often the hosting service provides a development toolkit to assist customers designing a web site. For more complex sites specialized design tools such as WordPress can be used to good advantage. If you want to outsource the design there are numerous companies that specialize in web site development.
Once created the various pages must be uploaded to the web server. The most popular method is File Transfer Protocol (FTP). Files are uploaded and managed used a FTP program such as WinSCP.
Search engines make it easy to find information on the internet by indexing and cataloging information. Search engines perform this task by using search bots, called spiders, to traverse Web hypertext structure. Spiders periodically visit millions of sites to maintain an up to date index of billions of web pages.
An informal internet standard has been developed to control the actions of these search engine spiders. When the spider first connects to a site it looks in the root directory for the file robots.txt. The purpose of robots.txt it to tell well behaved spiders, which web pages they are not supposed to index. Even if the site does not intend to prevent spiders from indexing pages it is a good idea to place a null robots.txt file in the root directory. This eliminates numerous entries in the server’s error log about access to a non-existent file.
# Created 2/25/2006
# All robots can spider domain
cPanel is a popular application used by both customers and hosting services to manage web, FTP, and email accounts. It also generates statistics to analyze who visits the site, what pages they view and how long they stay. Prior to the popularization of cPanel separate applications were used to manage customer account, create email accounts and generate usage statistics.
For example creating a new email account is as simple as entering an account name and password for that account.
Figure 37 Hosting Service cPanel Home Page
On occasion I’ve had instances where the site was inaccessible from some ISPs but not others. Uptrends has a nifty tool that accesses the site from multiple locations around the world and reports success/failure and latency.
Setting up a SOHO network has been an interesting and rewarding experience. The network meets our business and personal requirements. Higher speed internet access would be nice but our current DSL situation meets our needs.
Significant technical expertise is required to setup a network. The necessary components are readily available but amassing the knowledge needed to create and troubleshoot can be rather intimating. Each year more residential and SOHO networks are installed. Manufactures are getting better at designing customer friendly equipment. But one needs to be careful, sometimes ease of use brings with it security issues. In general failures are pretty straightforward to identify and fix once root cause is determined. However, determining root cause is not always easy. Help is available from many sources. Manufacturer-sponsored forums and specialized home network interest groups provide problem isolation and resolution help.